7KRPDV*XWNQHFKW DIALOG IN PHILOSOPHISCHER PRAXIS ,$QGHUH /lQGHU ± DQGHUH 6LWWHQ$QGHUH /HEHQVIRUPHQ DQGHUH .XOWXUHQ DQGHUH %HJULIIH 'DVNOLQJWWULYLDO'RFKZLUYHUJHVVHQHVVROHLFKW=XP%HLVSLHOEHLPYLHOEHVFKZRUHQHQÄ'LDORJGHU.XOWXUHQ³'RFKEHYRUHLQ'LDORJGHU.XOWXUHQVLQQYROOJHIKUWZHUGHQNDQQLVWHV VLFKORKQHQG]XHUVWHLQPDOEHUÄ.XOWXUHQGHV'LDORJV³QDFK]XGHQNHQ:LHVWHKWHVXPGDV 'LDORJYHUVWlQGQLV GHU %HWHLOLJWHQ" :DV EHGHXWHW 'LDORJ MHZHLOV LQQHUKDOE HLQHU EHVWLPPWHQ .XOWXURGHU/HEHQVIRUP":LHLVWHLQEHVWLPPWHV'LDORJYHUVWlQGQLVHLQJHEHWWHW"(LQH6LWXLHUXQJXQG.RQWH[WXDOLVLHUXQJGHV'LDORJVPVVWHDOOHQLQWHUNXOWXUHOOHQ'LDORJHQYRUDXVJHKHQ :DVNDQQRGHUVROOGHU'LDORJHUEULQJHQ",VWHUJHHLJQHW(LQPWLJNHLWXQG)ULHGHQ]XVWLIWHQ" 6ROOHU0LWWHOGHU:DKUKHLWV¿QGXQJVHLQ"(U|IIQHWHUHLQHQ%H]LHKXQJVUDXPXQWHU(EHQEUWLJHQ"(UVFKHLQWLQLKP±GLH+DXSWVDFKH±GDV'LDORJLVFKH" 0LW5HFKWQlPOLFKZLUGEH]ZHLIHOWGDVVPDQ'LDORJHJOHLFKVDPDOVHLQQHXWUDOH0HGLHQYHUVWHKHQGDUI(VJLEW'LDORJHGLHKHOIHQ*HOWXQJVDQVSUFKH]XYHUPLWWHOQ(VJLEWORJRVJHOHLWHWH 'LDORJHGLH]%HULVWLVFKHQDJRQDOHQGLGDNWLVFKHQRGHUV\QHUJLVWLVFKHQ&KDUDNWHUKDEHQ(V EHVWHKWHLQ,QWHUHVVHGHU9HUQXQIWDP'LDORJ'DQQLVWGHU'LDORJGLH(QWIDOWXQJGHV/RJRV 'RFKGDUIPDQDXFKGLH9HUQXQIWYRP'LDORJJHVFKHKHQKHUYHUVWHKHQ'LHMHQLJHQ3HUVRQHQ GLHLQ%H]LHKXQJVWHKHQWHLOHQHLQ,QWHUHVVHXQGVRUHDOLVLHUWGHU'LDORJSULPlUGLH=XZHQGXQJ GHU3HUVRQHQVRIHUQVLHHLQDQGHUMH]XVLFKVHOEHUEULQJHQ$XFKVFKRQLQQHUKDOEGHVNXOWXUHOOHQ:HVWHQV EHVWHKHQ YHUVFKLHGHQH Ä.XOWXUHQ³ GHV 'LDORJV 6R YHUOlXIW HLQ 'LDORJ LQ GHU 6SUDFKZHOWGHU3V\FKRORJLHDQGHUVDOVLQGHU3KLORVRSKLHXQGZLHGHUDQGHUVYHUKlOWHVVLFKLP $OOWDJVOHEHQ)RUPXQG=LHOVHW]XQJ9ROO]XJXQG)XQNWLRQN|QQHQNODUXQWHUVFKLHGHQZHUGHQ 8QGQLFKWQXU3HUVRQHQVSUHFKHQXQVDQDXFK(UHLJQLVVHÄVSUHFKHQ³XQGDXFKVLHYHUODQJHQ XQVHUHÄ$QWZRUW³DSSHOOLHUHQDQXQVHUH9HUDQWZRUWOLFKNHLW .XU]XPGDV7KHPDÄ'LDORJ³|IIQHWHLQZHLWHV)HOG:LUZROOHQXQVDQIlQJOLFKDQGLH6SUDFKH Q KDOWHQXQGXQV]XQlFKVWEHJULIÀLFKHXQGVDFKOLFKH'LIIHUHQ]HQYHUJHJHQZlUWLJHQ)U XQVHUH9HUVWlQGLJXQJGLHDXFKDXIGLHhEHUVHW]XQJVNXQVWYRP'HXWVFKHQLQV,WDOLHQLVFKHDQJHZLHVHQ LVW LVW HV MHGHQIDOOV YRQ JURHU7UDJZHLWH XQG %HGHXWXQJ GDVV LP 'HXWVFKHQ GDV :RUWÄ'LDORJ³HLQHHQJHUHXQGVSH]L¿VFKHUH%HGHXWXQJKDWDOVLP,WDOLHQLVFKHQ$QGHUHUVHLWV XQWHUVFKHLGHWPDQLP'HXWVFKHQ]ZLVFKHQ'LDORJXQG*HVSUlFKYRQ7HUPLQLZLH8QWHUUHGXQJ%HUDWXQJRGHU'LVNXUVHLQPDOJDQ]DEJHVHKHQ%HL(LQ]HOJHVSUlFKHQRGHUDXFK*UXSSHQJHVSUlFKHQLQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LVVSULFKWPDQJHZ|KQOLFKDEHUJHUDGHQLFKWYRQDialogen 197 S pazio aperto ,,2EZRKOLFKZHLOHVQDKHOLHJWZRKOXQWHUVWHOOHQGDUIGDVVYRQPLUHUZDUWHWZLUGDXI JHQDXGLHVH$UWYRQ*HVSUlFKHQQlKHUHLQ]XJHKHQP|FKWHLFKGLH&KDQFHQXW]HQGLHGLH Weite des Worts dialogoLP,WDOLHQLVFKHQDXIWXW6RNDQQLFKGLHYLHOXPIDVVHQGHUH5ROOHGHU 3KLORVRSKLVFKHQ3UD[LVLPLQQHUSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ'LVNXUVLKUH7KHRULHSHUVSHNWLYHHEHQVR LQV6SLHOEULQJHQZLHLKUH%HGHXWVDPNHLWLQGHU*HVHOOVFKDIWLP|IIHQWOLFKHQ5DXPJOHLFKVDPLKUH3UlVHQ]DXIGHU$JRUD 5HÀH[LYLWlW XQG 6SUDFKEHZXVVWVHLQ KLVWRULVFKH ,QIRUPLHUWKHLW XQG LGHRORJLHNULWLVFKH hEXQJDQDO\WLVFKHXQGKHUPHQHXWLVFKH.RPSHWHQ]HQXQGYRUDOOHPGDV,QWHUHVVHDQGHU )UHLKHLW SODW]LHUHQ 3KLORVRSKLVFKH 3UD[LV VR GDVV LKU HLQH EHVRQGHUH 9HUDQWZRUWXQJ ]XZlFKVWRGHUVFKRQ]XJHZDFKVHQLVWGLHEHUGLH9HUSÀLFKWXQJGHUDNDGHPLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHKLQDXVJHKW$OV$JHQWXUGHU)UHLKHLWEHJOHLWHWVLHNULWLVFK3ROLWLNHQgNRQRPLHQXVZ DXFKXQJHIUDJW6LHNDQQLP'LDORJYRQ:LUWVFKDIWXQG.XQVWYRQ:LVVHQVFKDIWXQG.LUFKH RGHUYRQ3ROLWLNXQG.XOWXU XPQXUHLQSDDU%HLVSLHOH]XQHQQHQ DOV0RGHUDWRULQXQG9HUPLWWOHULQhEHUVHW]HULQXQG3UR]HVVEHJOHLWHULQEHLVWHKHQ'LDORJHEHJOHLWHQXQGYHUPLWWHOQG GLHQHQ'HQQ3KLORVRSKLVFKH3UD[LVLVWEHUDOOGRUWZRSKLORVRSKLHUWZLUGXQGVROOWHEHUDOO GRUWZLUNHQZR3KLORVRSKLHQ|WLJLVW6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKDXFKLP)HOGGHUSHUV|QOLFKHQ/HEHQVIKUXQJVHLHVELOGHQGRULHQWLHUHQGRGHULQDQGHUHU)RUP $ 'RFK]XUFN]XP:RUWDialog'LDORJYHUZHQGHWPDQLP'HXWVFKHQHKHUÄWHFKQLVFK³XQG GD]XHUVWHLQPDODOV%H]HLFKQXQJIUHLQHliterarische Gattung6RVDJHQZLU]XP%HLVSLHO GDVV3ODWRQKHUYRUUDJHQGH'LDORJHJHVFKULHEHQKDEH2GHUGDVVGLH'DUVWHOOXQJGHU3KLORVRSKLHLQ'LDORJIRUP±QHEHQDQGHUHQP|JOLFKHQ)RUPHQGHV$XVGUXFNVYRQ*HGDQNHQZLH ]%7UDNWDW(VVD\$SKRULVPXV3DUDGR[LHXVZ±DPDOOHUEHVWHQ]XP9ROO]XJGHVSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ*HVFKlIWVMDZRP|JOLFKEHUKDXSW]XU6DFKHGHU3KLORVRSKLHSDVVH$XVVROFKHP 9HUVWlQGQLVN|QQWHDXFKdie Geschichte der Philosophie im Ganzen als ein fortdauernder Dialog EHJULIIHQ ZHUGHQ ± ZlUH GD QLFKW GDV HLQJDQJV JHlXHUWH %HGHQNHQ QlPOLFK GLH 'LYHUVLWlWYRQ'LDORJYHUVWlQGQLVVHQXQGLKU(LQJHEHWWHWVHLQLQ/HEHQVIRUPHQ'HQQVLFKHUOLFKKDEHQ'LDORJH DXFK%ULHIH7DJHEFKHU(UPDKQXQJHQDQVLFKVHOEVWXVZ GRUWHLQHQ VSH]L¿VFKHQZRP|JOLFKDXVJH]HLFKQHWHQ2UWZRGLH3KLORVRSKLHJDQ]XQPLWWHOEDUDXIGHQ 0HQVFKHQXQGVHLQH/HEHQVDUWEH]RJHQLVWXQGZLHHV3LHUUH+DGRWHLQGUXFNVYROOVFKLOGHUW LP*DQ]HQDXIGHQÄELRV³KLQXQG]XJOHLFKDXFKH[SOL]LWDOVÄSKLORVRSKLVFKH/HEHQVIRUP³ ]X GHQNHQ LVW 'HQQ LP 9HUJOHLFK KLHU]X KDW VLFK PLW GHP (LQEUXFK GHV &KULVWHQWXPV LQ GLH $QWLNH GLH 6LWXDWLRQ JUXQGVlW]OLFK YHUlQGHUW 1HEHQ GHU NXOWXUSUlJHQGHQ *HZLVVKHLW GHU*ODXEHQVPDFKWVSLHOWGLH3KLORVRSKLHMHW]WHLQHDQGHUH5ROOH'LHNLUFKOLFKH6HHOVRUJH 'DVJLOW]XPLQGHVWIUGLHDQGHU/HEHQVIRUPGHU0HQVFKHQSULPlULQWHUHVVLHUWHJULHFKLVFKH3KLORVRSKLH'D]X+HLQULFK5RPEDFK'LH*HJHQZDUWGHU3KLORVRSKLH)UHLEXUJ2WIULHG+|IIHKDW YRUJHVFKODJHQDQDORJ]XGHQYLHU.DUGLQDOWXJHQGHQYRQYLHU.DUGLQDOVSUDFKHQGHU3KLORVRSKLH]X VSUHFKHQ 3DUDGR[LHQ'LDORJH$EKDQGOXQJHQ$SKRULVPHQ 0LW5HFKWVWHOOWHUYRUDXVJHKHQGIHVW Ä'LH6SUDFKHGHV3KLORVRSKLHUHQVLVWPLWGHU$UWGHV'HQNHQVVRHQJYHUZREHQGDVVEHLGH'HQNHQ XQGVSUDFKOLFKH9HUIDVVWKHLWHLQHXQWUHQQEDUH(LQKHLWELOGHQ³ 2WIULHG+|IIH/HVKRPPHVVRQWVL QHFpVVDLUHPHQWIRXV$EVFKLHGVYRUOHVXQJ-XOLKWWSWLPPVXQLWXHELQJHQGH3OD\HU3OD\HU)ORZ87BBBKRHIIHB"VWDUWWLPH 198 Dialog in philosophischer Praxis S 7KRPDV*XWNQHFKW XQGGDVPRQDVWLVFKH/HEHQZHLVHQGHU3KLORVRSKLHDQGHUH$XIJDEHQ]XGLHGHUHQ9HUIDVVXQJ]ZDQJVOlX¿JYHUlQGHUW9HUNU]WJHVDJWZHQGHWGDV0LWWHODOWHUGHQDialog zum Disput E]Z ]XU Diskussion XQG GHU$XVWDXVFK GHU *HLVWHU ZLUG ]XP 6DFK XQG 0HLQXQJVVWUHLW GHUQLFKWPHKUGHU6HOEVWHUKHOOXQJGLHQWVRQGHUQHLQHUYHUELQGOLFKHQREMHNWLYHQ:DKUKHLW GLH(KUHJHEHQVROO9ROOHQGVDEHUYHUOLHUWGDV3KLORVRSKLHUHQGLH%H]LHKXQJ]XP'LDORJLQ GHU1HX]HLWHWZDLP5DWLRQDOLVPXVPLWVHLQHUzwingenden Argumentation und dem rein in VLFKVHOEVWEOHLEHQGHQPHWKRGLVFKHQ'HQNHQGHUQHXHQ:LVVHQVFKDIW$P(QGHVWHOOWVLFK GDQQGLH)UDJHREHVEHLVROFKHU9HUVFKLHGHQKHLWGHV3KLORVRSKLHUHQVEHUKDXSWHLQ8QLYHUVDOYHUKlOWQLVJHEHQNDQQVRGDVVYRQHLQHUSKLORVRSKLDSHUHQQLVHLQHULPPHUZlKUHQGHQ 3KLORVRSKLHQRFKJHVSURFKHQZHUGHQNDQQ.RQNUHWHUQRFKN|QQHQXQGGUIHQ.DQWXQG $ULVWRWHOHVVRLQHLQHQ'LDORJJHEUDFKWZHUGHQGDVVPDQDXIGHU(EHQHGHV$XVJHVDJWHQ EOHLEW"6FKDIIHQZLUQDFKZLHGHUKROWHQ7UDGLWLRQVEUFKHQHLQ%UFNHQEDXYRP+HXWHDXV KLQ]XUJULHFKLVFKU|PLVFKHQ*HLVWHVZHOW":HOFKHUKHUPHQHXWLVFKH.UDIWDNWLVWGDQ|WLJ" (LQH'LVNXVVLRQDXIGHU%DVLVGHUJHPHLQVDPHQ*ODXEHQVJUXQGODJHZLHVLHLP0LWWHODOWHUVHOEVWQRFKZLH7KRPDVYRQ$TXLQLQVHLQHUsumma contra gentilesDXIGHU%DVLVGHV 9HUQXQIWJODXEHQV]HLJW±P|JOLFKZDULVWMDQLFKW]XYHUJOHLFKHQPLWGHP'LDORJJHVFKHKHQ DQGHPXQV3ODWRQPLWVHLQHUNXQVWYROOHQ*HVWDOWXQJWHLOKDEHQOlVVW'RFKYHUVWHKHQZLUGHQ 'LDORJVRRKQH:HLWHUHVXQGDQJHPHVVHQ":LHGHUDQGHUVLVWGDV3KLORVRSKLHUHQDQJHOHJW DOVGHVVHQ$KQKHUUHQ'HVFDUWHVXQG6SLQR]DRGHU/HLEQL]JHOWHQ(LQHJDQ]QHXH)RUPGHU 6XEMHNWLYLWlWLVWMHW]WGLH+DXSWXUVDFKHIUGLH8QWHUVFKLHGH]ZLVFKHQGHUQHX]HLWOLFKHQXQG GHUDQWLNHQ3KLORVRSKLH'DVDOOHVNDQQLFKKLHUQXUDQGHXWHQ'LH$XIJDEHDEHULVWHLQGHXWLJDXFKGDJHKWHVJOHLFKVDPXPÄ.XOWXUHQ³8PVLHLQHLQHQ'LDORJ]XEULQJHQPXVVLKUH (LJHQDUWYHUVWDQGHQZHUGHQXQGEUDXFKWHVHLQXQLYHUVHOOHV'LDORJYHUVWlQGQLV$EHUJLEWHV GDV" $XFKIUGLH)UDJHQDFKGHP'LDORJin3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LVVLQGGLHVNHLQHXQHUKHEOLFKHQhEHUOHJXQJHQVRZHLWHVXPphilosophische*HVSUlFKHJHKW'DQQVWHKWMDDXFKGDV 9HUVWlQGQLVYRQ3KLORVRSKLHDXIGHP6SLHOE]ZNRPPWVLHDXIEHVWLPPWHZHLVHLQV6SLHO 'HQQLQGHU7DWKDWMDGDV*HVSUlFKGDVEHLVSLHOVZHLVHLQOLWHUDULVFKHQ'LDORJHQXQGDQGHUHQ7H[WVRUWHQGLHVHU=HLW %ULHIHHWF VHLQH6SLHJHOXQJ¿QGHWLQGHU3KLORVRSKLVFKHQ3UD[LV VHLQHQÄQDWUOLFKHQ³2UWZlKUHQGGDV9HUIDVVHQYRQ7UDNWDWHQRGHUGLHSKlQRPHQRORJLVFKH $QDO\VHHKHUDP6FKUHLEWLVFKRGHULP6HPLQDUJHOHLVWHWZLUGXQGHUVWWUDQVIRUPLHUWZHUGHQ PXVV ZHQQ HV XP GHQ SKLORVRSKLVFKHQ (LQVDW] LP *HVSUlFK JHKW ,Q GHU JHJHQZlUWLJHQ 3KLORVRSKLHIRUP DNDGHPLVFKXQLYHUVLWlU VLQGZLUSURIHVVLRQHOOHQ3KLORVRSKHQDEHUÄVR]LDOLVLHUW³(VZlUHQXQHLQIDWDOHU.XU]VFKOXVV]XPHLQHQPDQN|QQHLQXQYHUPLWWHOWHU:HLVH DOV(SLNXUlHU6WRLNHU6NHSWLNHURGHU3ODWRQLNHULQHLQHUZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKWHFKQLVFKHQ:HOW XQGPRGHUQHQ*HVHOOVFKDIWDXIWUHWHQ$XFKZHQQHV]XHLQHU5HKDELOLWDWLRQGHUSUDNWLVFKHQ 3KLORVRSKLHJHNRPPHQLVWXQGDXFKZHQQ]%GHV$ULVWRWHOHV7XJHQGOHKUHDQ$WWUDNWLYLWlW JHZRQQHQKDWLVWPDQQLFKWVFKRQHLQJXWHU3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UDNWLNHUZHLOPDQVLFKIU GLH6FK|QKHLWSODWRQLVFKHU'LDORJHGLH.UDIWGHUDULVWRWHOLVFKHQ7XJHQGOHKUHGHQ$GHOGHU +XPDQLWDVEHL&LFHURGLH6LWWOLFKNHLWHLQHV0DUF$XUHOEHJHLVWHUW:LHVFKZHUHVLVWPLW GHQ$OWHQZLUNOLFKLQV*HVSUlFK]XNRPPHQ±XQGZLHULVNDQWNDQQPDQEHL+HLGHJJHU VWXGLHUHQ +DQQDK$UHQGW KDW EHNDQQWOLFK OLHEHU 3ROLWLVFKH7KHRULH EHWULHEHQ DOV VLFK XP SKLORVRSKLVFKH3RVLWLRQHQ]XNPPHUQ:DVLFKPLWVROFKHQ$QGHXWXQJHQVDJHQZLOOLVW GDVVHLQH3KLORVRSKLVFKH3UDNWLNHULQXQGHLQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UDNWLNHUZLVVHQPVVHQZR 199 S pazio aperto LKUJHJHQZlUWLJHU2UWLQGHU3KLORVRSKLHLVW(LQHQ.XUVXVÄ6HQHFDIU*HVWUHVVWH³EHLGHP PDQVLFK]XVDPPHQPLW.OLHQWHQDQGHQ%ULHIHQDQ/XFLOLXVHUJ|W]WKDWZHQLJPLWXQVHUHP %HUXI]XWXQ+LQJHJHQLVWHLQH7UDQVIRUPDWLRQGHU3KLORVRSKLHDXIGHU+|KHLKUHUHLJHQHQ *HVFKLFKWHGHUJHVWDOWGDVVGHU%H]XJ]X)UDJHQGHU/HEHQVDUWZLHGHU]XUFN]XJHZRQQHQ ZLUGVFKRQHKHULKUH]XQlFKVWLQQHUSKLORVRSKLVFKHXQGUHÀH[LRQVEHGUIWLJH+HUDXVIRUGHUXQJXQG%HZlKUXQJVSUREH0LWDQGHUHQ:RUWHQ(LQHGHUZLFKWLJVWHQLQQHUSKLORVRSKLVFKHQ $XIJDEHQLQQHUKDOEGHU7KHRULHDUEHLWLQXQGIU3KLORVRSKLVFKH3UD[LVLVWHV3KLORVRSKLHDXI GHU+|KHYRQ+XVVHUOXQG:LWWJHQVWHLQQDFK.DQWXQG+HJHOPLW1LHW]VFKHXQG+HLGHJJHUHUQHXWDXIGLH/HEHQVIRUPHQXQG/HEHQVIKUXQJ]XEH]LHKHQ=XPLQGHVWEHVVHUDOVGLH ÄUHLQH3KLORVRSKLH³GHU6FKXOHVROOWHQ3UDNWLNHULQQHQXQG3UDNWLNHUGDUDXIYRUEHUHLWHWVHLQ XQGLP,QWHUHVVHLKUHU*l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lQGLJHQ%HLVROFKHQ'LDORJHQJHKWHVQLFKWMHGHQIDOOVYRQYRUQKHUHLQXPGLH 'XUFKVHW]XQJ YRQ ,QWHUHVVHQ RGHU XP 6HOEVWEHKDXSWXQJ 6R NDQQ DXFK YRQ HUJHEQLVRIIHQHQ'LDORJHQGLH5HGHVHLQRGHUYRQJHJHQVHLWLJHP/HUQHQ,QHLQHPVROFKHQ)DOOLVWGDV :RUW'LDORJDXVJHVSURFKHQSRVLWLYNRQQRWLHUW'LDORJLVWLP'HXWVFKHQJHUDGH]X]XHLQHP =DXEHUZRUWZRKOPHLQHQGHUXQGIULHGOLHEHQGHU=HLWJHQRVVHQJHZRUGHQ'HU'LDORJZLUGDOOHQWKDOEHQDQHPSIRKOHQXQGJHSÀHJWZRPDQVLFKDXI$XJHQK|KHXQGJHZDOWIUHLEHJHJQHQ ZLOO$OOHUGLQJVEOHLEWHULQGLHVHP6LQQHEHQHLQJHVFKUlQNWDXI=XVDPPHQKlQJHZLHÄ'LDORJGHU5HOLJLRQHQ³Ä'LDORJGHU.LUFKHPLWGHU VlNXODUHQ *HVHOOVFKDIW³RGHUÄGHU0RGHUQH³9LHOHURUWVZHUGHQ'LDORJSUR]HVVHLQLWLLHUWHWZDLQQHUKDOEGHU.LUFKHQRGHUDEHUDXFK DOV%UJHUEHWHLOLJXQJDQSROLWLVFKHQ3URMHNWHQhEHUDOOZHUGHQÄ5XQGH7LVFKH³DXIJHVWHOOW XQG 'LDORJUXQGHQ HLQJHULFKWHW Dialog heißt dabei: seine Interessen kommunizieren, Verständnis einwerben, unter Umständen verstehen lernen, weshalb man sich nicht einig wird XQGZHVKDOEHVVRVFKZLHULJLVW]XHLQHP.RPSURPLVV]X¿QGHQ,P'LDORJZHUGHQ.ULWHULHQ ]XU%HZHUWXQJYRQ,QWHUHVVHQYRUJHVWHOOW'DV(LQDQGHU.HQQHQOHUQHQLVWGDV+DXSW]LHOHLQ ZHLWHUHV0LWHLQDQGHUEHUGHQ3UR]HVVGHV0LWHLQDQGHUUHGHQVLP'LDORJJHVFKHKHQKLQDXV EUDXFKWQLFKWVWDWW]X¿QGHQ'LDORJLVWKLHUDOVHLQZHFKVHOVHLWLJHUhEHUVHW]XQJVSUR]HVVJHGDFKW'DV3ULQ]LSLVWGLH.RH[LVWHQ]LQ3OXUDOLWlWDXIGHU%DVLVYRQ'LDORJL]LWlW 'RFK VROFKH 'LDORJH YHUHLQHQ DP (QGH QLFKW VRQGHUQ EHIHVWLJHQ JHUDGH]X GHQ $Estand und die Fronten durch wechselseitige (durchaus legitime und positiv gemeinte) SelbVWUHFKWIHUWLJXQJHQ,PPHUKLQ]LHOHQVLHMDDXI5HVSHNWXQG7ROHUDQ]EHMDKHQGLH3OXUDOLWlW XQG'LYHUVLWlWGHUEHWHLOLJWHQ3HUVRQHQ0DQGDUIHUZDUWHQGDVVGDV0LVVYHUVWHKHQDEJHEDXW XQGHLQHHYHQWXHOOH)HLQGVHOLJNHLWEHUZXQGHQZLUG8QGGDVLVWQLFKWQLFKWV.RPPXQL- 200 Dialog in philosophischer Praxis S 7KRPDV*XWNQHFKW NDWLRQ LP HLJHQWOLFKVWHQ 6LQQ LVW GLHV DEHU QLFKW XQG ZLUG VRPLW QLFKW NRQVWLWXWLY IU GLH %LOGXQJYRQ*HPHLQVFKDIWHQ =ZLVFKHQ VROFKHQ ]XP 7HLO KRFKRI¿]LHOOHQ 'LDORJHQ XQG HLQIDFKHQ 8QWHUUHGXQJHQ LQ IUHXQGVFKDIWOLFKHQXQGDOOWlJOLFKHQ*HVSUlFKHQVLQGYLHOHUOHL'LVNXUVIRUPHQXQGVSUDFKOLFKH,QWHUDNWLRQHQDQJHVLHGHOW,FKHUZlKQHGLHDisputationGLHDebatteGLHDiskussionGHQ Meinungsaustausch und den Meinungsstreit GHQ Disput DEHU DXFK GLH Konversation und 8QWHUKDOWXQJGHQ3ODXVFKGDVJDQ]RIIHQH*HVSUlFKGDVVLFKEHL7LVFKRGHUDQGHUHQ*HOHJHQKHLWHQZLH]XIlOOLJHQWZLFNHOQNDQQ YRQ6PDOO7DONXQG3ODXGHUHLYRP*HUHGHXQG *HVFKZlW]HLQPDOJDQ]DEJHVHKHQ :LHDXFKLPPHUGDUEHUQXQDXVIKUOLFK]XVSUHFKHQ ZUGHGDV7KHPDYHUIHKOHQ]XGHP]XVSUHFKHQLFKHLQJHODGHQELQZHQQGLHhEHUVFKULIW ODXWHWÄ,OGLDORJRQHOODSUDWLFD¿ORVR¿FD³ ,,,'LH6WLFKZRUWHDXIGLHHVDQNRPPWVLQG]ZHLIHOORVÄGLDORJR³XQGÄSUDWLFD¿ORVR¿D³ ZREHLSUDWLFD¿ORVR¿DIUHLQ:RUW %HJULII ]XJHOWHQKDW:HQQHVEORDXIGLH9HUELQGXQJ YRQÄGLDORJR³XQGÄSUDWLFD¿ORVR¿D³DQNRPPHQKlWWHVROOHQXQGLFKHLQHQ9RUWUDJVWLWHOKlWWH VHOEVWHU¿QGHQGUIHQGDQQKlWWHLFKJHZlKOWÄ3KLORVRSKLVFKH3UD[LVist'LDORJ³RGHUÄ'LDlog ist3UD[LVGHU3KLORVRSKLH³ -HW]WDEHUKHLWGLH$XIJDEHÄ 'HU 'LDORJin3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LV³6LFKHUOLFKLVWGDPLWJHPHLQW,QZHOFKHU$UWXQG:HLVHIKUWPDQHLQ*HVSUlFKDOV3KLORVRSKXQG3KLORVRSKLQ PLWGHP3UD[LV*DVW"8QWHUVFKHLGHWVLFKHLQVROFKHV*HVSUlFKYRQDQGHUHQ*HVSUlFKVDQOlVVHQEHLVSLHOVZHLVHYRQ%HUDWXQJVJHVSUlFKHQLQNDWHJRULDOHU%HUDWXQJ mit einem Kunden RGHU YRQ HLQHU7KHUDSLHVWXQGH PLW HLQHP 3DWLHQWHQ" 8QG HWZDV WHFKQLVFKHU JHIUDJW:DV DOOHV LVW ]X EHDFKWHQ ZHQQ LQ 3KLORVRSKLVFKHU 3UD[LV *HVSUlFKH JHIKUW ZHUGHQ":HOFKH KlX¿JHUDXIWUHWHQGHQ6FKZLHULJNHLWHQJLEWHVGD":RUDXINRPPWHVOHW]WOLFKDQ"*LEWHVGD $QOHLWXQJHQ HWZD EHZlKUWH XQG DQJHPHVVHQH 0HWKRGHQ GHU *HVSUlFKVIKUXQJ" :RUDXI NRPPWHVEHUKDXSWLQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LVEHL*HVSUlFKHQDQ"*LEWHVGD+LQZHLVHDXV GHP UHFKWHQ" 9HUVWlQGQLVYRQ3KLORVRSKLH" ,FKVDJWHVFKRQGDVVEHLGLHVHP6HWWLQJRGHU)RUPDWXPGDVHVLP)ROJHQGHQJHKWLP Deutschen das Wort *HVSUlFK YHUZHQGHW ZLUG (V LVW HLQH (LJHQKHLW LP 'HXWVFKHQ GDVV PLWGHU9RUVLOEHÄ*H³:|UWHUJHELOGHWZHUGHQGLHHLQH9LHO]DKOYHUHLQLJHQYLHOH%HUJH KHLHQGeELUJHHLQH$QVDPPOXQJYRQ:DVVHUGeZlVVHUYLHOH:RUWHXP1LFKWVQHQQWPDQ GeUHGH,P*HVSUlFKQXQ¿QGHWHLQ0LWHLQDQGHUVSUHFKHQHLQ:RUWZHFKVHO]ZLVFKHQPLQGHVWHQV]ZHL6SUHFKHQGHQVWDWW6LQGHV]ZHL0HQVFKHQLPYHUWUDXWHQ*HVSUlFKNDQQPDQ DXFK=ZLHVSUDFKHVDJHQ (LQHFKWHV*HVSUlFKELOGHWHLQHQ*HVSUlFKV]XVDPPHQKDQJ6R EHUVHW]HLFKÄ,OGLDORJRQHOODSUDWLFD¿ORVR¿FD³PLWÄ'DV*HVSUlFKLQQHUKDOEGHU3KLORVRSKLVFKHQ3UD[LV RGHULP5DKPHQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LV ³RGHUEHVVHUXPGDV0RPHQW QRFKSUl]LVHU]XWUHIIHQGDVIUPLFKHQWVFKHLGHQGLVWÄ'DV*HVSUlFKLQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU Praxis alsHLQH3UD[LVGHV3KLORVRSKLHUHQV³ )UGDV:LFKWLJVWHKDOWHLFKZDVGDVEORHÄ)RUPDW*HVSUlFK³QLFKWVFKRQJDUDQWLHUW QlPOLFK GLH GLDORJLVFKH +DOWXQJ D 8QG IU HEHQVR ZLFKWLJ KDOWH LFK HV GDVV LQ 3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LV*HVSUlFKHGLH3UD[LVGHU3KLORVRSKLHHUNHQQHQODVVHQDOVRLPGeist der =%)LQDQ]EHUDWHU6WHXHUEHUDWHU%HUXIVEHUDWHUMXULVWLVFKH%HUDWXQJ9HUNDXIVEHUDWXQJXVZ 201 S pazio aperto PhilosophieJHIKUWZHUGHQPhilosophische3UD[LVKHLWSKLORVRSKLVFKSUDNWL]LHUHQSKLORVRSKLHUHQEHVVHUPLWHLQDQGHUSKLORVRSKLHUHQ'DUDXVIROJWIUPLFKHUVWHQV3KLORVRSKLH ZLUG QLFKW ÄDQJHZHQGHW³ 3KLORVRSKLVFKH 3UD[LV LVW NHLQH DQJHZDQGWH 3KLORVRSKLH VRQGHUQHEHQ3UD[LVGHU3KLORVRSKLH=ZHLWHQV3UDNWLVFKZLUG3KLORVRSKLHQLFKWGHVKDOEZHLO VLH )UDJHQ GHV DOOWlJOLFKHQ /HEHQV XQG GHU /HEHQVIKUXQJ DXIJUHLIW VRQGHUQ LQVRIHUQ VLH /HEHQVWKHPHQ LP ,QWHUHVVH GHU )UHLKHLW GXUFKGHQNW E 3KLORVRSKLVFKH 3UD[LV LVW NRRSHULHUHQGHV'HQNHQGDV 6HOEVW (UNHQQWQLVXQG$XINOlUXQJXPGHU3HUVRQKDIWLJNHLWXQGGHU 6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ ZLOOHQ DQVWUHEW 8QG ZHLO QLHPDOV YRP DUFKLPHGLVFKHQ 3XQNW DXV SKLORVRSKLHUW ZLUG VROOWH GULWWHQV 5HFKHQVFKDIW DEJHOHJW ZHUGHQ N|QQHQ EHU$XIIDVVXQJHQ GLH IU GDV HLJHQH 3KLORVRSKLHUHQ XQG GLH HLJHQH 3UD[LV OHLWHQG VLQG HWZD ZHOFKHV 0HQVFKHQELOGPDJHEOLFKLVWZHOFKH,GHHYRQGHU3KLORVRSKLHXQGLKUHQ=LHOHQPDQKDWXVZ F 2KQH+LQZHLVHDXIGLHVH*UXQGODJHQKlWWHQPHLQH,GHHQ]XU3UD[LVGHV'LDORJVXQG]XU &KDUDNWHULVWLNYRQ*HVSUlFKHQLQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LVNHLQHYHUQQIWLJH*UXQGODJH,FK NDQQGLHVHQ+LQWHUJUXQGMHW]WDOOHUGLQJVQLFKWHQWIDOWHQ.HQQHUZHUGHQOHLFKWKHUDXVK|UHQ ZHOFKH$XWRUHQPLU/HKUHULPEHVWHQ6LQQJHZRUGHQVLQG'LHKLHUHLQVFKOlJLJHQÄ0HLVWHU³ VLQG 0DUWLQ%XEHU 0D[ 6FKHOHU .DUO -DVSHUV XQG +DQQDK$UHQGW+DQV*HRUJ *DGDPHU XQG -UJHQ +DEHUPDV GLH LKUHUVHLWV RKQH 3ODWRQ$ULVWRWHOHV$XJXVWLQXV XQG .DQW QLFKW GDKLQJHNRPPHQZlUHQZRZLUVLHDQWUHIIHQVLHVWHKHQDXIGHQ6FKXOWHUQYRQ5LHVHQ$EHU XPQLFKWPLVVYHUVWDQGHQ]XZHUGHQ,Q3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LVDUEHLWHWPDQQLFKWVRGDVV PDQ$ULVWRWHOHVRGHU.DQWVSUHFKHQOlVVW0DQKlOWHVPLWGHQ*URHQZLHHLQJXWHU6HHOVRUJHUGHUVLFKYRP*HLVW*RWWHVLQVSLULHUHQOlVVWGHUVSULFKWDXFKQLFKWLPPHU]Xvon Gott oder EHU*RWWVRQGHUQLP6WLOOHQmit*RWW±EHUGLHLKPDQYHUWUDXWHQ0HQVFKHQXQGYRQGRUW her zu diesen Menschen und mit ihnen6RDXFKHLQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UDNWLNHUHULVWLPPHU ZLHGHU±LP6WXGLXP±LPLQQHUHQ*HVSUlFKPLWGHQ0HLVWHUQXPVHOEHUGDV3KLORVRSKLHUHQ ]XOHUQHQ3KLORVRSKLVFKH3UDNWLNHUJHKHQPLWGHQ$OWHQXPZLHPLWEULOODQWHQ.ROOHJHQXP VLFKSKLORVRSKLVFK]XELOGHQ$XVGLHVHP8PJDQJEHNRPPWGLHJHLVWLJH1DKUXQJGLHPDQ VSlWHUVHOEVW]XJHEHQYHUPDJ6XEVWDQ] 'DV6WXGLXPLVWHLQHhEXQJLP9HUVWHKHQGLHXQVEHLP9HUVWHKHQGHU*lVWHXQGLKUHU $QOLHJHQ]XJXWHNRPPW%HL*HOHJHQKHLWGHV6WLFKZRUWVÄ+HUPHQHXWLN³GLHHLQH6FKOVVHOGLV]LSOLQIU3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LVLVW±HLQH=ZLVFKHQEHPHUNXQJ,FKPXWH,KQHQOLHEH +|UHULQQHQ XQG +|UHU MD HLQLJHV ]X ZHQQ LFK 'HXWVFK VSUHFKH XQG 6LH HLQH LWDOLHQLVFKH hEHUVHW]XQJ]XK|UHQEHNRPPHQ'LHVLVWDOOHUGLQJVNHLQ0DQJHO(VELHWHWHLQHKHUYRUUDJHQGH&KDQFH]XU(LQEXQJLQGLH.XQVWGHV9HUVWHKHQV(VLVWDEHUQLFKWQXUHLQHhEXQJLQ 6DFKHQ+HUPHQHXWLNHVLVWDXFKHLQH(LQODGXQJ]XP'LDORJ±GHUVLFKYRU]JOLFKDOOHUGLQJV LQ,KUHPHLJHQHQ.RSI]XWUlJW6LHZHUGHQNUHDWLYVHLQEHLP9HUVWHKHQXQGHVZLUGMHZHLOV GDEHLHWZDVMH(LJHQHVHWZDV3HUV|QOLFKHVHQWVWHKHQ'LHVZUGHXQWHUEOHLEHQZHQQHVPLU VSUDFKOLFKP|JOLFKZlUH6LHUKHWRULVFKHLQ]XZLFNHOQRGHUVFKOLPPHUQRFKYROONRPPHQ JHVFKORVVHQH$UJXPHQWDWLRQVNHWWHQ XP 6LH ]X KHUXP]XOHJHQ VR]XVDJHQ ]ZLQJHQG ]X DUJXPHQWLHUHQ6ROFKH0RQRORJLNGLHLQGHU6FKXOSKLORVRSKLHJDQJXQGJlEHLVWSDVVWDEHU QLFKW]XU3UD[LVGHV3KLORVRSKLHUHQVLQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LV Ä$XWRULWlWHQ³ SDVVW QLFKW ]XU )RUP GHU 3KLORVRSKLH DOOHQIDOOV9RUELOGHU Ä.PPHUW HXFK QLFKW XP 6RNUDWHVNPPHUWHXFKXPGLH:DKUKHLW³RGHUDXFKÄ3ODWRQLVWPLUWHXHUDEHUQRFKWHXUHUGLH:DKUKHLW³ 202 Dialog in philosophischer Praxis S 7KRPDV*XWNQHFKW 'LH 'LIIHUHQ] XQVHUHU 6SUDFKHQ HU|IIQHW EHL QRFK VR JHNRQQWHU hEHUVHW]XQJ HLQH JURH=DKOYRQ/FNHQGLHMHGHU]HLWHLQH)OXFKWYRUPHLQHQ XQYHUPHLGOLFKHQ LQWHOOHNWXHOOHQ1|WLJXQJVYHUVXFKHQJHVWDWWHQ*HZLVVLFKZLOOYHUVWDQGHQZHUGHQ8QGPLW.DQWVDJH LFKYLHOEHVVHULVWHVPLU]XZLGHUVSUHFKHQDOVPLFKQLFKW]XYHUVWHKHQ8QGGHQQRFKZLH SURGXNWLYVLQGJHUDGHGLH0LVVYHUVWlQGQLVVH"(VJLEWNHLQHQ*UXQG]XU.RQWUROOHLP*HVSUlFK0LWEHLGHQ*HVSUlFKVSDUWQHUQJHVFKLHKWLP*HVSUlFK8QYRUKHUVHKEDUHV'DV*HVSUlFKIKUWXQVQLFKWDOOHLQZLUHLQ*HVSUlFK/DVVHQZLUXQVEHUUDVFKHQMHGHQIDOOVDEHU QLFKW EORFNLHUHQ GXUFK LP 9RUDXV JHVWHFNWH =LHOH 'DQQ K|UW GDV IUHLH *HVSUlFK DXI XQG GLH3KLORVRSKLVFKH3UD[LVZLUGHLQVWUDWHJLVFKHV8QWHUQHKPHQ(VJLEWHLQHZRKOEHJUQGHWH 'LIIHUHQ]]ZLVFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHXQG6RSKLVWLN'LDORJNDQQ]XP(UNHQQWQLVPLWWHOZHUGHQ 'LDORJNDQQHLQH)RUPGHU'LGDNWLNVHLQHVJLEWQHEHQGLGDNWLVFKHQMDDXFKHULVWLVFKHXQG DJRQDOH*HVSUlFKHDEHUGDVHLJHQWOLFKHXQGDXFKYRQ3ODWRQJHVXFKWHÄHFKWH³*HVSUlFKLVW HLQV\QHUJLVWLVFKHVZRGLH3DUWQHUPLWHLQDQGHUHLQHQ:HJEHVFKUHLWHQGHUVLFKJOHLFKVDP XQWHULKUHQ)HQHUJLEW ,P*HVSUlFKEHNXQGHWVLFK=XJHZDQGWKHLW,P*HVSUlFKNRPPWHLQVFK|SIHULVFKHV0RPHQW]XP=XJ3RHWLVFKHLQ]HOQVLQGZLU:RUWH]XVDPPHQHLQ*HGLFKW,QV*HVSUlFKJHKW GDV (LJHQH HLQ XQG ZLUG (LJHQHV ZLHGHU IUHL JHJHEHQ :LH VHKU HLQ$XVWDXVFK YRQ GHP JHSUlJWLVWZDVPDQVHOEVWDOV3URSULXPPLWEULQJWXQGHLQJLEWP|FKWHLFKPLWIROJHQGHU NXU]HQ*HVFKLFKWHYHUDQVFKDXOLFKHQ>:LUGHQWVSUHFKHQGPLW*HVWHQYRUJHIKUWE]ZXQWHUVWULFKHQ@(LQ&RZER\XQGHLQ,QGLDQHUWUHIIHQVLFKLQGHU3UlULH'HU,QGLDQHU]HLJWPLWGHP =HLJH¿QJHUDXIGHQ&RZER\'HUKHEWDOV$QWZRUW=HLJH¿QJHUXQG0LWWHO¿QJHUJHVSUHL]W KRFK 'HU ,QGLDQHU IDOWHW GLH +lQGH YRU GHP *HVLFKW ZLH ]X HLQHU *HVWH GHU %LWWH 'HP EHJHJQHWGHU&RZER\PLWHLQHU:LVFKEHZHJXQJGHU+DQG LQ5LFKWXQJ+DQGUFNHQ $QVFKOLHHQGUHLWHQEHLGHGDYRQ'HU&RZER\NRPPWQDFK+DXVH]XVHLQHU)UDXXQGHU]lKOW Ä6WHOO¶GLUYRULFKKDEHKHXWHHLQH5RWKDXWJHWURIIHQ6LHKDWPLWGHP=HLJH¿QJHUJHGURKW PLFK]XHUVFKLHHQ'DKDEHLFKGHP,QGLDQHUPLWGHU+DQGEHGHXWHWGDVVLFKJOHLFKDXI ]ZHL 5RWKlXWH VFKLHHQ ZUGH 'RFK ZHLO HU XP *QDGH JHZLQVHOW KDW KDEH LFK LKP ]X YHUVWHKHQ JHJHEHQ HU VROOH YHUVFKZLQGHQ³ (LQLJH 0HLOHQ ZHVWOLFK LP :LJZDP HU]lKOW GHU,QGLDQHUVHLQHU6TXDZÄ6WHOO¶GLUYRULFKKDEHKHXWHHLQQHWWHV%OHLFKJHVLFKWJHWURIIHQ ,FKIUDJHÃ:LHKHLWGX"µ(UDQWZRUWHWÃ=LHJHµ'DIUDJLFKÃ%HUJ]LHJH"µXQGHUDQWZRUWHW Ã1HLQ)OXVV]LHJHµ³±(LQHZLHLFK¿QGHVFK|QH*HVFKLFKWHYRQGHUNXOWXUDEKlQJLJHQ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQHLQXQGGHVVHOEHQ(UHLJQLVVHV 'DV:LFKWLJHDQGLHVHUKEVFKHQ*HVFKLFKWHLVWHLQHVHKUHUQVWH6DFKH:LUN|QQHQDXFK KLHU ZLHGHU JXW VHKHQ GDVV HV VLFK EHL *HVSUlFKHQ QLFKW ]ZDQJVOlX¿J XP HLQ 'LDORJJHVFKHKHQ KDQGHOW +LQWHU (UVFKHLQXQJVIRUPHQ GHV 'LDORJV E]Z *HVSUlFKV N|QQHQ VLFK LQ :LUNOLFKNHLWSDUDOOHOYHUODXIHQGH0RQRORJHYHUEHUJHQ(LQ'LDORJLVWGDQXUXQWHUVWHOOWRGHU YRUJHWlXVFKW(QWVFKHLGHQGIUGHQ'LDORJXQGHUVWUHFKWIUGDV*HVSUlFKLPHQJHUHQ6LQQ ist aber das 'LDORJLVFKH3ULQ]LS oder die Dialogik,VWGLHGLDORJLVFKH(LQVWHOOXQJRGHU+DOWXQJQLFKWJHJHEHQZLUGHLQ'LDORJ]XU)DUFH'DQQUHGHQGLH/HXWHLQLKUHU6HOEVWEH]RJHQKHLW EHVWlQGLJ DQHLQDQGHU YRUEHL GHU RGHU GLH DQGHUH LVW DOOHQIDOOV 6WLFKZRUWJHEHU IU GHQHLJHQHQ5HGHVFKZDOO:LHGHUHLQDQGHUHUPDFKWLQSlGDJRJLVFKHURGHUWKHUDSHXWLVFKHU (LQVWHOOXQJVHLQ*HJHQEHU]XP2EMHNWE]ZVLHKWGHQDQGHUHQQXUDOV4XHOOHIUDOOHP|JOLFKHQ,QIRUPDWLRQHQDQGLHHUEHULKQVDPPHOW:LHRIWVSULFKWPDQQXUEHUHLQDQGHUVWDWW HLQDQGHUDQ]XVSUHFKHQ" 203 S pazio aperto $XFK EORH %H]XJQDKPH DOV VROFKH LVW QLFKW VFKRQ GLDORJLVFK 0LW 5HFKW VDJW 0DUWLQ %XEHUGHVKDOEÄ,FKNHQQHGUHLHUOHL'LDORJGHQHFKWHQJOHLFKYLHOJHUHGHWHQRGHUJHVFKZLHJHQHQZRMHGHUGHU7HLOQHKPHUGHQRGHUGLHDQGHUHQLQLKUHP'DVHLQXQG6RVHLQZLUNOLFK PHLQWXQGVLFKLKQHQLQGHU,QWHQWLRQ]XZHQGHWGDVVOHEHQGLJH*HJHQVHLWLJNHLWVLFK]ZLVFKHQLKPXQGLKQHQVWLIWHWGHQWHFKQLVFKHQGHUOHGLJOLFKYRQGHU1RWGXUIWGHUVDFKOLFKHQ 9HUVWlQGLJXQJHLQJHJHEHQLVWXQGGHQGLDORJLVFKYHUNOHLGHWHQ0RQRORJLQGHP]ZHLRGHU PHKUHUHLP5DXP]XVDPPHQJHNRPPHQH0HQVFKHQDXIZXQGHUOLFKYHUVFKOXQJHQHQ8PZHJHQMHGHUPLWVLFKVHOEHUUHGHQ³8QGDQDQGHUHU6WHOOHÄ'LDORJLVFKHV/HEHQLVWQLFKWHLQV LQGHPPDQYLHOPLW0HQVFKHQ]XWXQKDWVRQGHUQHLQVLQGHPPDQPLWGHQ0HQVFKHQ PLWGHQHQPDQ]XWXQKDWZLUNOLFK]XWXQKDW0RQRORJLVFKOHEHQGLVWQLFKWGHU(LQVDPH]X QHQQHQVRQGHUQZHUQLFKWIlKLJLVWGLH*HVHOOVFKDIWLQGHUHUVLFKVFKLFNVDOVPlLJEHZHJW ZHVHQVPlLJ]XYHUZLUNOLFKHQ³ (LQ,QGLYLGXXPNRPPXQL]LHUWQLFKW(VQLPPWWHLODQHLQHU.RPPXQLNDWLRQ(VLVWQLFKW $XWRUGHU.RPPXQLNDWLRQHVLVWSDVVLYDNWLYEHWHLOLJW.RPPXQLNDWLRQLVWQLFKWQDFKGHP 0RGHOOYRQ$NWLRQXQG5HDNWLRQ]XYHUVWHKHQVRQGHUQQXUDXIGHU(EHQHGHV$XVWDXVFKV )UGLHVHHFKWH%HJHJQXQJLVWGHU$XVGUXFNÄLQ.RQWDNWNRPPHQ³YLHO]XVFKZDFK3HULFKRUHVHWULIIWHVVFKRQHKHU (V JHKW LP HFKWHQ *HVSUlFK ZHLWHU GDUXP GDVV GHU DQGHUH 0HQVFK DOV GLHVHU$QGHUH DOV GLH ZLUNOLFK HLJHQVWlQGLJH DQGHUH 3HUVRQ JHPHLQW ZDKUJHQRPPHQ XQG LQHLQV GDPLW DXFKDQHUNDQQWZLUG$QHUNHQQXQJLVWQLFKWQXUGLH+HU]PLWWHGHU(WKLNVRQGHUQDXFKGHV 'LDORJV *HUDGH GDV *HVSUlFK LVW HLQH 4XHOOH GHU (WKLN$P HKHVWHQ ZLUG$QHUNHQQXQJ YHUZLUNOLFKWZHQQGLH0HQVFKHQGLHPLWHLQDQGHU]XWXQEHNRPPHQIUHLQDQGHUVLFKWEDU ZHUGHQ6RJLOW6SULFKGDPLWLFKGLFKVHKH2KQHGLH%HUHLWVFKDIWGHQ$QGHUHQDOV$Qderen an]XHUNHQQHQ YHUIHKOH LFK LQ GHU %HJHJQXQJ GLH GDQQ ]XU 9HUJHJQXQJ ZLUG GHV $QGHUHQ:LUNOLFKNHLWVFKRQDXIGHU(EHQHGHVErNHQQHQV(UNHQQHQXQG$QHUNHQQHQIDOOHQ ]XVDPPHQ (LQH GLDORJLVFKH +DOWXQJ YHUODQJW 5FNKDOWORVLJNHLW LQ GHU %HJHJQXQJ QLFKW QXU3HUV|QOLFKNHLWVRQGHUQ3HUVRQKDIWLJNHLW'DVEHGHXWHWGDVVVWUDWHJLVFKHV+DQGHOQ]X NHLQHPZLUNOLFKHQ'LDORJRGHU*HVSUlFKIKUHQNDQQ'DVJLOWDXFKQRFKIUWKHUDSHXWLVFKH RGHUSlGDJRJLVFKH,QWHUYHQWLRQHQ$QGHUVJHVDJW1LFKWPLWGHP'LDORJIlQJWDOOHVDQXQG GHUSUDNWL]LHUWH'LDORJVWHKWQLFKWDP$QIDQJ9LHOPHKUKDEHQ'LDORJKDEHQ*HVSUlFKXQG =ZLHVSUDFKHVHOEHULKUHUVHLWV9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQden dialogischen SinnGLH5LFKWXQJYRP ,FK]XP'XYRUDOOHPGLHUFNKDOWORVHXQGYRUEHKDOWORVH+LQZHQGXQJ]XP'XYRUGHP PDQVLFKZLHHVHWZDLP2VWHQJHVFKLHKW]XDOOHUHUVW]XYHUQHLJHQKDW )U GLH 3KLORVRSKLVFKH 3UD[LV JLOW GDV 3ULQ]LS Ä'LDORJ VWDWW 'LDJQRVH³ hEULJHQV DXFK 'LDORJVWDWW8QWHUZHLVXQJ'HU'LDORJLVWGLH7KHUDSLH ,FKVSUHFKH±ZLH6LHEHPHUNHQ LP'HXWVFKHQQXQGRFKÄWHFKQLVFK³ZHQQLFKLP6LQQH%XEHUVGDVZDKUKDIWGLDORJLVFKH *HVSUlFKPHLQHXQGYHUZHQGHGRFKGDV:RUWÄ'LDORJ³±HEHQLQHLQHPJDQ]VSH]L¿VFKHQ 6LQQ (VLVWZLFKWLJHUGLH)UHLKHLWDQ]XUXIHQDQVWDWWPLWZHOFKHP$QOLHJHQDXFKLPPHU DXIGHQDQGHUHQLQGHUHLQHQRGHUDQGHUHQ:HLVHHLQ]XZLUNHQ $XIHLQHVHKUVFK|QH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQGHVMDSDQLVFKHQ'LFKWHUV8HGDKDWPLFKPHLQH.ROOHJLQ(YD6FKLIIHUDXIPHUNVDPJHPDFKW6LHUHIHULHUWGDVVGHU6LQQGHU9HUQHLJXQJGDULQ (YD6FKLIIHU YRUGHULFKPLFKPHLQHUVHLWVYHUQHLJH LQGHP0DQXVNULSWÄ%UFNHQEHU$EJUQGH³ HUVFKHLQWLP-DKUEXFKGHU,*33Kulturen des Dialogs. Vermittlungen Philosophischer Praxis 204 Dialog in philosophischer Praxis S 7KRPDV*XWNQHFKW EHVWHKHVLFKIUHLXQGJHJHQVHLWLJDOV(JR]XQLFKWH]XPDFKHQXPLQGHQ8UVSUXQJHLQHV =ZLVFKHQHLQ]XWDXFKHQZRHVZHGHU,FKQRFK'XJLEW'LH3DUWQHUVWHKHQVLFKZLHGHU DXIULFKWHQGDOV,FK'XXQG'X,FKJHJHQEHU6RZLUGDQJH]HLJWZLHDEVROXWH6HOEVWlQGLJNHLWXQGY|OOLJH$QJHZLHVHQKHLWDXIHLQDQGHU]XVDPPHQJHK|UHQ,QGHU8QWHUVFKHLGXQJ ]ZLVFKHQGHP6HOEVWXQGGHP$QGHUHQEOHLEWDP*UXQGGHV6XEMHNWVHLQVLQGHU7LHIHHLQH 6SKlUH ZR HV 'LIIHUHQ]LHUXQJHQ QLFKW JHEHQ NDQQ 3HWUD YRQ 0RUVWHLQ VSULFKW LQ$QOHKQXQJDQ.DQWVÄ,FKGDVLQXQVDOOHQGHQNW³YRQHLQHPÄ,FKGDVLQXQVDOOHQ HU OHEW³RGHU ÄGHP6XEMHNWGDVLQXQVDOOHQLVW³(VLVWHLQPHQVFKOLFKHV3DUDGR[GDVVEHVRQGHUVLQ([WUHPVLWXDWLRQHQLFKPLUHLQHUVHLWVQlKHUELQDOVVRQVWREZRKODQGHUHUVHLWVGLHLQGLYLGXHOOHQ *UHQ]HQGHV,FK]XYHUVFKZLQGHQDQIDQJHQ-HGHV(UOHEHQDXFKGDVDOOWlJOLFKHKDWHLQHQ 6XEMHNW$VSHNWGHULQGHUREMHNWLYHQ%HVFKUHLEXQJQLFKWDXIJHKW:LUVLQGDOV2EMHNWHYRQHLQDQGHUXQWHUVFKHLGEDUGRFKDOV6XEMHNWHXQWUHQQEDU0LW0DUWLQ%XEHU'XVDJHQGZHUGH LFK]XP6XEMHNW:HQQLFKÄ,FK(V³VSUHFKHVSULFKWJOHLFKVDPHLQQRFKQLFKWZHVHQKDIWHV XQG DQGHUHV ,FK DOV EHLP Ä,FK'X³6DJHQ (UJlQ]HQ P|FKWH LFK 'LH$QGHUKHLW EHVWHKW VFKRQLP6XEMHNW,FKELQLQPLUVHOEVWGHUGHUPLWVLFK]XWXQKDW'DVVWHKWQLFKWLP*HJHQVDW]]X%XEHUV'LDORJLVFKHP3ULQ]LSVRQGHUQHQWVSULQJWGRUWZRDXFKGDV'LDORJLVFKH 3ULQ]LSHQWVSULQJW ,QGHQ*HVSUlFKHQGLHLFKLP%OLFNKDEHJHKWHVQLFKW]XOHW]WXP6HOEVWerkenntnis,P ,QWHUHVVHGHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJLVWGLHREMHNWZHOWOLFKH2ULHQWLHUXQJXQGVDFKOLFKREMHNWLYH (LQVWHOOXQJHEHQVRZLFKWLJZLHGLH6HOEVWHUKHOOXQJ*HUDGHGLHEUDXFKWQRWZHQGLJGHQDQGHUHQDOV*HVSUlFKVSDUWQHU,QQHQVFKDXJHQJWQLFKW %G6LHKH]XP+LQWHUJUXQGDXFK)UDQFRLV-XOOLHQDenkzugänge. Mögliche Wege des Geistes%HUOLQ XQGIUKHUGHUV'LH$IIHQEUFNH3DVVDJHQ:LHQ 9JO3HWUDYRQ0RUVWHLQErleben als Ursprung Philosophischen Fragens. Dialog in Philosophischer Praxis6LQ7KRPDV*XWNQHFKWHWDO +J %HUDWXQJXQG%LOGXQJ%HUOLQ -DKUEXFKGHU ,*33%G 'LH:HOWLVW]ZLHIlOWLJJHPlGHU=ZLHIDOWGLHVHU*UXQGZRUWHGLH:RUWSDDUHVLQGHEHQ,FK(VRGHU ,FK'X *lQ]OLFK 6XEMHNW XQG 3HUVRQ ZHVHQVPlLJ 0HQVFK ELQ LFK QXU LQ GHU %H]LHKXQJ ,Q GLHVHP(LQVN|QQHQZLU]ZDUQLFKWYHUEOHLEHQ+lWWHGLHV%HVWDQGZUGHQ3V\FKRORJHQHLQH3V\FKRVH IHVWVWHOOHQ$EHUZLUGUIHQDXFKQLFKWEHUVHKHQGDVVLQGLHVHUXQYRUGHQNOLFKHQ7LHIHGHUGRSSHOWH *UXQGYRQ6XEMHNWVHLQXQG,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWEHVWHKW,P'LDORJNRPPWGLHVHSDUDGR[H9HUIDVVXQJ GHV0HQVFKHQGHUNRQNUHWLPPHUVFKRQ0LWPHQVFKLVW]XP$XVGUXFN'LH,FK'X%H]LHKXQJLVW NHLQH SV\FKRORJLVFKH 6WUXNWXU VRQGHUQ YHUZHLVW EHU GDV ,QQHUVHHOLVFKH KLQDXV DXI HLQH ZLUNOLFKH 9HUELQGXQJGHUMHGHUYRQEHLGHQVHLQHHLJHQH,GHQWLWlWYHUGDQNW'DVOlVVWVLFKDPHKHVWHQLQHLQHUUHODWLRQDOHQ2QWRORJLHEHVFKUHLEHQ$EHUGLHVHPHWDSK\VLVFKH9HUDQNHUXQJGHV'LDORJLVFKHQLQHFKWHQ 'LDORJHQ DOV6HLQVYHUKlOWQLV NDQQLFKMHW]WQLFKWDXVIKUHQ(VLVWDEHULPPHUPLW]XEHGHQNHQ 9RQ1DWXUDXVLVWMHGHUYRQXQVYRQHLQHP(JR]HQWULVPXVJHSUlJWGHUGD]XIKUWGDVVHLQ/HEHZHVHQ ]XQlFKVWDQGHUH]XJXQVWHQGHV(JRPDQLSXOLHUHQZLOO'RFKGDV5HDOLWlWVSULQ]LSEULQJWGDV/XVWSULQ]LSLPPHUPHKUDQ*UHQ]HQ6RZLUGGDV(JRDQVLFKVHOEVW]XUFNYHUZLHVHQXQGEHJLQQWHLQHQLQQHUHQ'LDORJ'LHVH)RUPYRQ6XEMHNWLYLWlWLVWVREHKDXSWHLFKJOHLFKXUVSUQJOLFKPLW%XEHUV3RVLWLRQ 9RUDXVVHW]XQJIUMHGHQ'LDORJPLWHLQHPDQGHUHQ$QGHUHQ 3HWHU%LHULÄ'RFKZLHJHQDXPDFKHQZLUGDVXQVEHIUDJHQXQVYHUVWHKHQXQVYHUlQGHUQ"(VKDWYLHO PLW6SUDFKH]XWXQ±PLWGHP)LQGHQGHUULFKWLJHQ:RUWHIUGDVZDVZLUGHQNHQXQGHUOHEHQhEHU VLFKVHOEVW]XEHVWLPPHQNDQQKHLHQVLFKLPHLJHQHQ'HQNHQ]XRULHQWLHUHQXQGVHLQHhEHU]HXJXQJHQDXIGHQ3UIVWDQG]XVWHOOHQ>«@,QGHPLFKQDFK%HOHJHQIURGHUJHJHQJHZRKQWHhEHU]HXJXQJHQVXFKHHU|IIQHLFKHLQHQLQQHUHQ3UR]HVVLQGHVVHQ9HUODXIVLFKGLHVHhEHU]HXJXQJHQlQGHUQ N|QQHQ8QGZHQQGLHVHU3UR]HVVZHLWOlX¿JJHQXJLVWNDQQGDV]XHLQHU8PJHVWDOWXQJPHLQHVJDQ]HQ 205 S pazio aperto :HQQ0HQVFKHQLP*HVSUlFKLQGHU3UD[LVHU]lKOHQHUOHEHLFKHVVRGDVVVLHPLUQLFKW etwas EHULKUH:HOWDQVFKDXXQJPLWWHLOHQ9LHOPHKULVWHVVRGDVVVLHaus GLHVHUVSUHFKHQ 6LHVDJHQQLFKWHLJHQWOLFKZDVVLHGHQNHQVRQGHUQLKU'HQNHQVDJWVLFK8QGLPOHEHQGLJHQ *HVSUlFKPLWPLUNDQQVLFKLKU'HQNHQHUQHXHUQ(LQ*HGDQNHQLFKWQXUJHGDFKWVRQGHUQ DXVJHVDJWLVWHLQ]ZHLWHU*HGDQNH,P+|UHQXQG0LWGHQNHQYHUYLHOIlOWLJWVLFKGDVQRFK %HLGHU3UD[LVGHU0HLQXQJVSUIXQJEHLGHU6XFKHQDFKXQGEHLP6WUHLWXPGHQÄEHVWHQ/RJRV³LVWGDV6XEMHNWYRUDOOHPHLQ$UJXPHQWDWLRQVVXEMHNW,FKHUZlKQWHVFKRQGDV HULVWLVFKH *HVSUlFK GDV DJRQDOH *HVSUlFK XQG GDV GLGDNWLVFK *HVSUlFK ,P *UXQG OLHJW LQDOOHQ)lOOHQWURW]GHU'LDORJIRUPHLQ0RQRORJYRU:HQQGHU6SUHFKHQGH%HVFKHLG]X ZLVVHQPHLQWHQWZLFNHOWHU±LGHDOW\SLVFK±HLQHQLQVLFKNRQVHTXHQWHQHLQGLPHQVLRQDOIRUWODXIHQGHQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ HU EHJUQGHW GLHVHQ JHJHQEHU P|JOLFKHUZHLVH DXIWDXFKHQGHQ =ZHLIHOQVLFKHUWLKQJHJHQ(LQZHQGXQJHQLVWDXFKLPVWDQGHDP$QIDQJQRFKYHUERUJHQH .RQVHTXHQ]HQ]X]LHKHQ$EHUGDEHLNRPPWQLFKWV1HXHVKHUDXV,QGLHVHU+DOWXQJJLEWHV HQWZHGHU6LHJHUXQG%HVLHJWHRGHU/HKUHQGHXQG%HOHKUWH6ROFKPRQRORJLVFKHV6SUHFKHQ LVW]XJOHLFKHLQDXWRULWDWLYHV6SUHFKHQ'LH'DUVWHOOXQJVROOÄ]ZLQJHQG³VHLQXQGGHP$QGHUHQNHLQHQ=ZHLIHOXQGNHLQHQ:LGHUVSUXFKHUODXEHQ'DVVGLH%HJUQGXQJÄ]ZLQJHQG³ VHLQVROOLVWHLQHEH]HLFKQHQGYHUUlWHULVFKH:HQGXQJGHQQVLHEULQJW]XP$XVGUXFNGDVV GLHVH6SUHFKIRUPDXIHLQHP+HUUVFKDIWVGHQNHQEHUXKWZHQQDXFKDXIHLQHPÄQXU³LQWHOOHNWXHOOHQ*HELHW$XFKGDQQLVWVLHDEHUJHZDOWI|UPLJ 0HLQXQJVSUR¿OVIKUHQ]XHLQHU9HUlQGHUXQJPHLQHUJHGDQNOLFKHQ,GHQWLWlW'HVKDOELVWGHU3UR]HVV GHU$XINOlUXQJEHUHLQHZLFKWLJH6DFKHHLQ$NWGHU6HOEVWEHVWLPPXQJ³Ä,P3UR]HVVGHV1DFKSUIHQVEHUQLPPWPDQVHOEVWGLH5HJLHEHUVHLQ'HQNHQ'DVKDWYLHOPLWNULWLVFKHU'LVWDQ]DXFKJHJHQEHUGHQHLJHQHQVSUDFKOLFKHQ*HZRKQKHLWHQ]XWXQ9LHOHVZDVZLU]XGHQNHQXQG]XZLVVHQPHLQHQ LVWGDGXUFKHQWVWDQGHQGDVVZLUGLH0XWWHUVSUDFKHQDFKJHSODSSHUWKDEHQ(VVLQG'LQJHGLHPDQHEHQ VRVDJW,P'HQNHQVHOEVWlQGLJHUPQGLJHU]XZHUGHQEHGHXWHWZDFKHU]XZHUGHQJHJHQEHUEOLQGHQ VSUDFKOLFKHQ*HZRKQKHLWHQGLHXQVQXUYRUJDXNHOQGDVVZLUHWZDVGHQNHQ$OOHVZHLWHUHHUVFKOLHW VLFKQLFKWPHKUGXUFKHLQH.RQ]HQWUDWLRQQDFKLQQHQ$FKWVDPNHLWXQG$XIPHUNVDPNHLWKHOIHQQLFKW PHKUYLHOEHLGHU9HUJHZLVVHUXQJEHUWLHIHUOLHJHQGHhEHU]HXJXQJHQ+RIIQXQJHQXQG%HIUFKWXQJHQ(LQHVROFKH9HUJHZLVVHUXQJYHUODQJWGHQ%OLFNYRQDXHQQLFKWYLHODQGHUVDOVEHLGHP9HUVXFK HLQHQ$QGHUHQ]XYHUVWHKHQÄ%HLDOOGLHVHQ'LQJHQEHWUDFKWHPDQVLFKQLFKWDOV%HZRKQHUHLQHULQ VLFKWUDQVSDUHQWHQ,QQHQZHOWGLHGHU$XHQZHOWDEJHVFKORVVHQJHJHQEHUVWQGHVRQGHUQDOV7HLOGHU :HOWLQVJHVDPWGHUVLFKXQWHUGHP(LQÀXVVGHUDQGHUHQ7HLOHYHUlQGHUWXQGHQWZLFNHOW³9JO3HWHU Bieris Vortrag „Wie wäre es, gebildet zu sein?“)HVWUHGHDQGHU3lGDJRJLVFKHQ+RFKVFKXOH%HUQEHU %LOGXQJYRP1RYHPEHU ,FKYHUWUHWHHLQH3RVLWLRQMHQVHLWVYRQ5HODWLYLVPXVXQG)XQGDPHQWDOLVPXV'DVVGLHUHODWLYLVWLVFKH 3RVLWLRQ QLFKW VHOEVWDQZHQGEDU LVW IKUW VLH VFKRQ DG DEVXUGXP 'D]X GDVV HLQ 0HQVFK HLQ )XQGDPHQW IU GLH ,GHQWLWlW LQ hEHU]HXJXQJHQ EHQ|WLJW LVW DQ]XPHUNHQ GDVV GLHV ]ZDU LQ HLQHQ IXQGDPHQWDOLVWLVFKH+DOWXQJIKUHQNDQQDEHUQXUGDQQZHQQGHU*HOWXQJVE]Z:DKUKHLWVDQVSUXFK PLVVYHUVWDQGHQZLUG(LQH:LUNOLFKNHLWGHU]X8QUHFKW)XQGDPHQWDOLVPXVYRUJHKDOWHQZLUGLVWGDV NLUFKOLFKH'RJPD(LQ'RJPDVLFKHUWGLH8QDEVFKOLHEDUNHLWHLQHU)UDJHHLQHU6SDQQXQJ]%GDV 9HUKlOWQLVYRQ*RWWXQG0HQVFKGDVHLQH+lUHVLHDXÀ|VWLQGHPVLHHLQHQ3ROGHU6SDQQXQJQHJLHUW +lUHVLHQ IKUHQ GDKHU ]XP )XQGDPHQWDOLVPXV QLFKW DEHU HLQH:DKUKHLW Ä'LH ZLOGH:DKUKHLW KlOW VLFKVFKZDQNHQGDXIUHFKW³'DV'RJPDYHUVXFKWGLH:DKUKHLWGLHVFKZDQNWGXUFKGLH-DKUKXQGHUWH ]X UHWWHQ 'DV ZLUG YHUVWlQGOLFKHU ZHQQ PDQ GLH 'UHLVWX¿JNHLW LP:DKUKHLWVJHGDQNHQ VLHKW 6DFKZDKUKHLW :DKUKHLWGHU'LQJH9HUKlOWQLVVH GLHDEHULPPHU±DOVXQVHU=XJDQJGD]XHLQH (QWVSUHFKXQJLP6XEMHNWKDEHQPVVHQ UHODWLRQDOQLFKWUHODWLYLVWLVFK GDVVHLQHUVHLWVLPLQWHUSHUVRQDOHQ:DKUKHLWVUDXPDOVRGHPZDVVLFKGDV]ZLVFKHQ3HUVRQHQ]XWUlJWYHUDQWZRUWHWZHUGHQ 206 Dialog in philosophischer Praxis S 7KRPDV*XWNQHFKW 2WWR)ULHGULFK%ROOQRZVFKUHLEWKLHU]XÄ'DV]HLJWVLFKEHVRQGHUVGHXWOLFKLQGHUUHLQVWHQ )RUPHLQHVVROFKHQPRQRORJLVFKGHPRQVWULHUHQGHQ'HQNHQVGHP%HZHLV'HU%HZHLVKDW LPPHUHWZDV1DFKWUlJOLFKHV(UJHKWDXVYRQHLQHU%HKDXSWXQJXQGVXFKWQDFKWUlJOLFKGDIU HLQH%HJUQGXQJ³'DVKDWYRULKP+DQV/LSSVVHKUNODUKHUDXVJHVWHOOWÄ'HU%HZHLV>LVW@ DQ LKP VHOEHU HLQH 'HPRQVWUDWLRQ 'HP DQGHUHQ ZLUG HWZDV EHZLHVHQ >@ 1DFKJHWUDJHQ ]XZHUGHQLVWGHP%HZHLVZHVHQWOLFK=XU6LFKHUXQJEHZHLVWPDQHWZDV>@>'DUXP@KDEHQ%HZHLVHLPPHUHWZDV$JJUHVVLYHV3ROHPLVFKHV'HQQ%HKDXSWXQJHQZHUGHQEHZLHVHQ 3RVLWLRQHQ GXUFK$UJXPHQWH JHVLFKHUW >«@ 'HU JHJHQ GHQ PDQ HWZDV EHZHLVW ZLUG JH]ZXQJHQPLW]XJHKHQHVVLFKEHZHLVHQ]XODVVHQGDVV>@³%ROOQRZÄ'LH'LVNXVVLRQ XQWHUVFKHLGHWVLFKYRPHLJHQWOLFKHQ*HVSUlFKGDGXUFKGDVVVLHDOVHLQH)ROJHYRQPLWHLQDQGHUVWUHLWHQGHQNOHLQHUHQ0RQRORJHQDXI]XIDVVHQLVW-HGHUHLQ]HOQH%HLWUDJLVWQDFK$UWGHV 0RQRORJVLQVLFKDEJHVFKORVVHQ'HU6SUHFKHQGHKDWHLQ5HFKWGDUDXIQLFKWXQWHUEURFKHQ ]XZHUGHQXQGHUVWZHQQHUIHUWLJLVWVHW]W LQHLQHPJHRUGQHWHQ0RQRORJ GHUDQGUHPLW HLQHUHEHQIDOOVLQVLFKJHVFKORVVHQHQ(UZLGHUXQJHLQ'DV*DQ]HLVWHLQ.DPSI]ZLVFKHQ GHQ3RVLWLRQHQGLHQLFKWHUVWLQGHU'LVNXVVLRQJHZRQQHQZHUGHQVRQGHUQVFKRQYRUGHU 'LVNXVVLRQ IHVWVWHKHQ DEHU LQ GHU 'LVNXVVLRQ DXI GLH 3UREH JHVWHOOW XQG HUKlUWHW RGHU DOV XQEUDXFKEDU YHUZRUIHQ ZHUGHQ VROOHQ³ 0LW +DQV /LSSV Ä0DQ YHUWULWW >«@ HLQH 7KHVH GDV5HFKWHLQHV6WDQGSXQNWHV>@'LVNXVVLRQLVWHLQDJRQDOHU/RJRVVFKODJHQGH*UQGH %HZHLVDQWUHWHQXVZ³ VROO :DKUKHLWSHUVRQDO 'DQQLVWHVDEHUJHUDGHVRGDVVLFKMHPDQGPHLQH:DKUKHLW]XPXWHQPXVV 'HQQZHQQLFKQLFKWPHKUEHNHQQHXQGQLFKWPHKUZLGHUVSUHFKHVFKOLHHLFKGHQ:DKUKHLWVUDXPGHU LPPHUHLQ%H]LHKXQJVUDXPLVW(QWVFKHLGHQGGDEHLLVWQDWUOLFKNHLQH*HZDOWNHLQH0DQLSXODWLRQ ,FKPXVVGHQDQGHUHQLQVHLQHUSHUVRQDOHQ,QWHJULWlWEHODVVHQN|QQHQGDUIDOVRZHUEHQDEHUVROOWH QLFKW EHUUHGHQ ZROOHQ *HQDXVR W|GOLFK ZLH GLH %H]LHKXQJVYHUZHLJHUXQJ ZlUH QLFKW HUQVWKDIW ]X UHGHQXQGPHKUQRFKDOVGDVGLH/JHDOVEHVRQGHUH)RUPYRQ*HZDOW/JHLVW%H]LHKXQJVYHUZHLJHUXQJXQGJHLVWLJH*HZDOWWlWLJNHLWVFKRQZHLOGHU:DKUKHLW*HZDOWDQJHWDQZLUGGLHGXUFKVFKOlJWDXI 0HQVFKHQGLHLKU/HEHQLQ:DKUKHLWHQJUQGHQPVVHQ.XU]XP'LH2SWLRQIU PHLQH :DKUKHLW GLHLPEHVWHQ)DOOGLHDOOHU9HUQQIWLJHQRGHU0LW*ODXEHQGHQLVW LVWDOOHVDQGHUHDOV=XÀXFKWLQGHQ Fundamentalismus! (LQ%HZHLVLVWGLHGHU0DFKWEHKDXSWXQJGXUFKGLHUDWLRQDOH0DFKWGHU$UJXPHQWH6RLVWGHU%HZHLV HLQ0LWWHOLQGHUNlPSIHULVFKHQ$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ=XQlFKVWZDUHUEHKHLPDWHWLQGHUJHULFKWOLFKHQ 6SKlUHZR3DUWHLHQVWUHLWHQ'HUNlPSIHULVFKH=XJNRPPWDXFKQRFKLQGHUZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHQ'LVNXVVLRQRGHUSDUODPHQWDULVFKHQ'HEDWWHQ]XP$XVGUXFN9JO2WWR)ULHGULFK%ROOQRZDas Doppelgesicht der Wahrheit. Philosophie der Erkenntnis%DQG6WXWWJDUWEHVRQGHUV6 ,PEHVWHQ)DOOJLEWHVLQGHQVDFKEH]RJHQHQDUJXPHQWLHUHQGHQ*HVSUlFKHQHLQHJHPHLQVDPH:DKUKHLWVVXFKH GLH VLFK LP NRRSHUDWLYHQ 6DFKJHVSUlFK YROO]LHKW (V KDQGHOW VLFK GDQQ EHUHLWV XP HLQ HFKWHV*HVSUlFK(VXQWHUVFKHLGHWVLFKYRQGHU'LVSXWDWLRQGDGXUFKGDVVKLHUGLH8QWHUEUHFKXQJLQ HLQHU]ZDQJORVHQ)RUPMHGHQ$XJHQEOLFNP|JOLFKLVWXQGXPVRIUKHUHLQVHW]WMHOHEKDIWHUXQGGDPLW IUXFKWEDUHUGDV*HVSUlFKZLUG(UVWDQ(LQZUIHQDP:LGHUVWDQGGXUFKXQYRUKHUVHKEDUH8QWHUEUHFKXQJHQGXUFKGHQ*HVSUlFKVSDUWQHUHQW]QGHWVLFKGDVVFK|SIHULVFKH'HQNHQ2IWNDQQGDVULFKWLJH :RUWHUVWJHIXQGHQZHUGHQZHQQGLH(QWJHJQXQJQLFKWQXUDOV:LGHUVWDQGDXIWULWWVRQGHUQGHQ*HGDQNHQLPSURGXNWLYHQ6LQQDXIQLPPWXQGZHLWHUIKUWXQGVREHUHLFKHUQGDXIGHQHUVWHQ6SUHFKHU ]XUFNZLUNW(VEHVWHKWLQHLQHPEHVWlQGLJHQ3UR]HVVGHVZHFKVHOVHLWLJHQ8QWHUEUHFKHQVXQG)RUWIKUHQVDQGHPEHLGH6HLWHQJOHLFKPlLJEHWHLOLJWVLQG-DPDQNDQQJHUDGH]XVDJHQ'DV*HVSUlFK HQWZLFNHOWVLFKXQJHSODQWZLHYRQVHOEVWDXVHLJHQHU*HVHW]PlLJNHLW'HU$QIDQJLVWPHLVW]XIlOOLJ JHZLVVHUPDHQQXUGHU$QVWRXQGHUVWLQZHFKVHOVHLWLJHU6WHLJHUXQJNRPPWHVGDQQZLHLQHLQHP 5HVRQDQ]YRUJDQJ]XPZLUNOLFKHQ*HVSUlFK'HU6LQQGHUVLFKLP*HVSUlFKHUJLEWOLHJWGDQQQLFKW 207 S pazio aperto 'RFKGDV*HVSUlFKLQGHU3KLORVRSKLVFKHQ3UD[LVLVWVHOWHQHLQ6DFKJHVSUlFKLPKHUN|PPOLFKHQ 6LQQ :DV GD LQVJHKHLP RGHU DXVGUFNOLFK JHVXFKW ZLUG LVW SHUVRQKDIWH$QHUNHQQXQJGXUFKHLQZLUNOLFKHV*HJHQEHUYRUGHPPDQXQGPLWGHPPDQGHQNW(VJHKWXPVR HWZDV ZLH:LUNOLFKZHUGHQ .DUO -DVSHUV GD]X Ä:HVHQWOLFKH GDV 6HLQ WUHIIHQGH:DKUKHLW HQWVSULQJWQXULQGHU.RPPXQLNDWLRQDQGLHVLHJHEXQGHQLVW'DKHUNDQQZDKUH3KLORVRSKLH QXULQ*HPHLQVFKDIW]XP'DVHLQNRPPHQ'LH.RPPXQLNDWLRQVORVLJNHLWGHV3KLORVRSKHQ ZLUG HLQ .ULWHULXP GHU 8QZDKUKHLW VHLQHV 'HQNHQV³ 'LH 6HOEVWZHUGXQJ VFKOLHW JHZLVV HLQHQ.DPSIXP:DKUKHLWHLQ:RHLQHULPPHUQXU]XVWLPPWNRPPWNHLQHFKWHV*HVSUlFK ]XVWDQGH$EHUGHU:LGHUVSUXFKLVWXPIDQJHQYRQHLQHUJUXQGVlW]OLFKHQ=XZHQGXQJ-DVSHUVVFKHXWVLFKQLFKWGDV:RUW/LHEH]XJHEUDXFKHQ(UVSULFKW]XJOHLFKYRQHLQHP.DPSI GRFKHVÄLVWQLFKWGHU.DPSI]ZHLHU([LVWHQ]HQJHJHQHLQDQGHUVRQGHUQHLQJHPHLQVDPHU .DPSI JHJHQ VLFK VHOEVW XQG GHQ DQGHUHQ DEHU DOOHLQ .DPSI XP:DKUKHLW³ 'DVV HV EHL GHU%H]LHKXQJ]XP'XDQHLQHUVDFKRULHQWLHUWHQ(LQVWHOOXQJQLFKWIHKOHQVROOWHEHWRQW9LWWRULR+|VOHÄ'DV)DV]LQLHUHQGHXQGDXIGHQHUVWHQ%OLFNhEHUUDVFKHQGHDQGHUVDFKRULHQWLHUWHQ(LQVWHOOXQJLVWGDVVVLHHLQHEHVVHUH*UXQGODJHIUHLQHJHOLQJHQGHSKLORVRSKLVFKH ,QWHUVXEMHNWLYLWlWGDUVWHOOWDOVMHQH(LQVWHOOXQJGLHSULPlUDXIGLH$QHUNHQQXQJGHVDQGHUHQ DEKHEW GHQQ$FKWXQJ ZLUG QRUPDOHUZHLVH JHUDGH GDQQ QLFKW HU]LHOW ZHQQ VLH LQWHQWLRQH UHFWDDQJHVWUHEWZLUG±MHGHQIDOOVGLH$FKWXQJGHUHUDXIGLHHVDQNRPPW (LWOH0HQVFKHQ P|JHQHVGXUFKDXVYRU]LHKHQGDVVPDQVLHXPZLUEWVWDWWVLFKXPGLH/|VXQJHLQHV6DFKSUREOHPVEHPKW (LQIUXFKWEDUHV*HVSUlFKGUHKWVLFKVWHWVXPHLQH6DFKHXQGQXUGLHMHQLJHQ 0HQVFKHQVLQGDOV3HUVRQHQLQWHUHVVDQWGLHYRQHLQHPVROFKHQ6DFKLQWHUHVVHEHVHHOWVLQG³ 'DV.OlUHQYRQ6DFKHQXQGGDV6WlUNHQYRQ3HUVRQHQNDQQPDQQLFKWDXVHLQDQGHUGLYLGLHUHQ 6FKOLHOLFKLVWMDGDV/HEHQXQG(UOHEHQHLQHV%HVXFKHUVHEHQGLHÄ6DFKH³XPGLHHVJHKW GHU*HJHQVWDQGGHV*HVSUlFKV*HJHQVWDQGZHUGHQVHLQH$QJVWVHLQH6RUJHQVHLQH)UDJHQ VHLQHEHODVWHQGH9HUJDQJHQKHLWVHLQH(KHDXFKVHLQ+RIIHQVHLQ*OFNVHLQH'DQNEDUNHLW ±DOOGDVLVWHLQP|JOLFKHU*HVSUlFKVLQKDOWE]ZJHJHQVWDQG*HVSUlFKHLQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU 3UD[LVEHWUHIIHQGHQ%LOGXQJVSUR]HVVGHU3HUVRQXQGLKUH6HOEVWZLUNVDPNHLW,FKYHUVXFKH GLH6HOEVWDQQDKPH]XXQWHUVWW]HQGLHGLH9RUDXVVHW]XQJGDIULVWGDVVVLFKHLQ0HQVFK GHQ%OLFNLQGLHHLJHQH$EJUQGLJNHLWOHLVWHQNDQQXQGEHUHLWLVWDXIHLQ9HUVWHFNVSLHOYRU VLFKVHOEVWXQGDQGHUHQ]XYHU]LFKWHQYRP6HOEVWEHWUXJXQGYRQ,OOXVLRQHQEHUGDV/HEHQ DE]XODVVHQ XQG LQ GLHVHP 6LQQ GHVLOOXVLRQLHUW HUZDFKVHQ ]X ZHUGHQ 'HU =XVDPPHQKDQJ YRQ6HOEVWELOGXQJXQGPHQVFKOLFKHU5HLIXQJLVWDXIVHOEVWNULWLVFKHV'HQNHQDOVhEXQJVZHJ DQJHZLHVHQ:HQQGDHLQ3DUWQHURIIHQXQGSUlVHQWDOV*HJHQEHUGDLVWNDQQHLQÄ6LFK 9RUZDJHQDXIHLQ(QWJHJHQNRPPHQ]X³EHJLQQHQ DXIGHUHLQHQRGHUGHUDQGHUQ6HLWHVRQGHUQJHZLVVHUPDHQÄ]ZLVFKHQ³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|VOHDer philosophische Dialog0QFKHQ6 208 Dialog in philosophischer Praxis S 7KRPDV*XWNQHFKW 'LHVHUVFK|QH$XVGUXFNVWDPPWYRQ.(/¡JVWUXSGHQPLUPHLQ.ROOHJH$QGHUV/LQGVHWKEHNDQQWJHPDFKWKDW$QGHUV/LQGVHWKVHOEVWKDWLP$QVFKOXVVDQGLH$UEHLWHQYRQ /¡JVWUXSZLFKWLJH.RQVHTXHQ]HQIUGLH*HVSUlFKHLQGHU3KLORVRSKLVFKHQ3UD[LVJH]RJHQ XQGKDWVHLQH(LQVLFKWHQ]XVDPPHQIDVVHQGYRUJHWUDJHQLQGHPZLFKWLJHQ$XIVDW]Ä9RQGHU 0HWKRGHGHU3KLORVRSKLVFKHQ3UD[LVDOVGLDORJLVFKHU%HUDWXQJ³,FKZLOOQLFKWGLHP|JOLFKHQ(LQZlQGHJHJHQÄ0HWKRGHQ³RGHUGHQ%HJULIIÄ%HUDWXQJ³YRUEULQJHQVRQGHUQDXIJUHLIHQZRUXPHVLQGHU+DXSWVDFKHJHKWQlPOLFKGDVVGDV3UD[LVJHVSUlFKHLQ3UR]HVVVHLQVROO LQGHPHLQH/HEHQVWKHPDWLNKHUYRUWUHWHQNDQQ'LHVGDVVHLQH/HEHQVWKHPDWLNKHUYRUWULWW LVWQLFKWVRVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKZLHHVVFKHLQW0HQVFKHQVLQGLQYLHOHU+LQVLFKW2SIHULKUHU VHOEVWXQGGDPLWPHLQHLFKGDVVVLHVLFKVHOEVWDXIGHQ/HLPJHKHQ6LHHU]lKOHQVLFKVHOEVW LQGHP VLH *HVFKLFKWHQ ÄHU¿QGHQ³ GLH LQ HLQ JDQ]HV *HZHEH YRQ /JHQJHVFKLFKWHQ HLQJHZREHQVLQG,QHLQHUJDQ]NODVVLVFKHQ:HLVHNDQQPDQPLWGHP8QWHUVFKLHGYRQ6FKHLQ XQG6HLQRSHULHUHQ6HOWHQZLUG(UOHEWHVVR]XU6SUDFKHJHEUDFKWXQGLQV%HZXVVWVHLQJHKREHQGDVVHVGHQWDWVlFKOLFKHQ8PVWlQGHQXQG9HUKlOWQLVVHQJHUHFKWZLUG8QVHU=XJULIIDXI GLHHLJHQHQ(UIDKUXQJHQLVWJHIRUPWYRQ$XVGUXFNVP|JOLFKNHLWHQXQG%HJULIÀLFKNHLWHQGLH GLH/JHEHJQVWLJHQ(VLVWGHVKDOEVFKRQYLHOJHZRQQHQZHQQEHUKDXSWHLQ2UWEHUHLW JHVWHOOWZLUGDQGHPMHPDQGVLFKDQJHPHVVHQDXIGLH+HUDXVIRUGHUXQJHQHLQODVVHQNDQQ GLHGDV/HEHQPLWVLFKEULQJW:LHOHLFKWNDQQHVJHVFKHKHQGDVVGLHNULWLVFKH8UWHLOVNUDIW XQGVHOEVWlQGLJHV8UWHLOVYHUP|JHQDXVJHVFKDOWHWZHUGHQ]XPDOGDQQZHQQPDQEHVHVVHQ LVWYRQGHU,GHHDOOHVULFKWLJPDFKHQ]XPVVHQ'LH.RORQLDOLVLHUXQJGHU/HEHQVZHOWGXUFK 6\VWHPHLVWHLQZLFKWLJHV)RUVFKXQJVWKHPDYRQ-UJHQ+DEHUPDVJHZHVHQ$QGHUV/LQGVHWK JUHLIWGDVDXIXQGVDJWÄ'LH/RJLNGHU5LFKWLJNHLW³ZHOFKHGLH6\VWHPHUHSUlVHQWLHUHQ 2SWLPLHUXQJGXUFK6WHXHUXQJXQG6LFKHUXQJ ÄVROOYHUKLQGHUQGDVVZLU)HKOHUPDFKHQDEHU GDGXUFKZHUGHQZLUVRVHKUGDPLWEHVFKlIWLJWDOOHVULFKWLJ]XPDFKHQVRGDVVZLUXQVQLFKW PHKUIUDJHQREXQVHUULFKWLJHV7XQYLHOOHLFKWXQNOXJRGHUXQHWKLVFKLVW6RYHUVXFKHQZLU QLFKWQXUGDV'XPPH]XYHUPHLGHQVRQGHUQZLUYHUOLHUHQDXFKGDV.OXJHDXVGHQ$XJHQ 'DPLWNDQQV\VWHPDWLVFKH5LFKWLJNHLW]XNRQVHTXHQWHU'XPPKHLWZHUGHQ8QGLFKIUFKWH GDVVGLHVH.RQVHTXHQ]OHLFKWHUXQGVFKQHOOHUHLQWULIIWDOVZLUPHLQHQ³ ,Q GHU 9HUDQWZRUWXQJ GHV 3KLORVRSKHQ VWHKW EHL HLQHP VROFKHQ *HVSUlFK GDVV HU GHP 6LHKH$QGHUV/LQGVHWKVon der Methode der Philosophischen Praxis als dialogischer Beratung,LQ 'HWOHI6WDXGH +J Methoden philosophischer Praxis. Ein Handbuch%LHOHIHOG6 9RQGLHVHU$QDO\VHDXVJHKHQGXQWHUVFKHLGHW/LQGVHWK]ZLVFKHQ$UWHQYRQ0HWKRGHQ'DVLVWVRZLFKWLJZHLOGDPLWJH]HLJWZHUGHQVROOZHOFKHU0HWKRGHQEHJULIIJHPHLQWLVWZHQQPDQEHUKDXSWYRQ HLQHU *HVSUlFKVPHWKRGH VSUHFKHQ ZLOO (LQHUVHLWV JLEW HV VROFKH ÄGLH GLH 0|JOLFKNHLW ELHWHQ GDVV LQHLQHPJHSODQWHQ3UR]HVVHWZDVHQWVWHKHQNDQQXQG0HWKRGHQGLHYHUKLQGHUQVROOHQGDVVHWZDV 1HXHV XQG 8QHUZDUWHWHV HLQWULIIW 0HWKRGHQ GHU HUVWHQ$UW ODGHQ JOHLFKVDP GDV /HEHQ HLQ HLJHQH 3UlPLVVHQ]XP$XVGUXFNNRPPHQ]XODVVHQZlKUHQG0HWKRGHQGHU]ZHLWHQ$UWDOOH3UlPLVVHQVHOEVW VHW]HQXQGGDV*HVFKHKHQVWUHQJNRQWUROOLHUHQ'LHVH]ZHL0HWKRGHQDUWHQN|QQHQZLUGLDORJLVFKHXQG PRQRORJLVFKH0HWKRGHQQHQQHQ:HQQZLUHLQHUGLDORJLVFKHQ0HWKRGHIROJHQEH¿QGHQZLUXQVLQ HLQHP*HVSUlFK±PLW0HQVFKHQPLWGHU1DWXUPLWHLQHP0DWHULDO±XQGLQGLHVHP'LDORJZLUGVLFK ]HLJHQZDVP|JOLFKRGHUYHUQQIWLJLVW]XWXQRGHU]XPHLQHQ³,PDQGHUHQ)DOOGDVKHLWZHQQPDQ PRQRORJLVFKHQ0HWKRGHQIROJWZLUGVWHWVYRP6XEMHNWEHVWLPPWZDVJHVFKHKHQVROO7ULIIWHWZDV 8QHUZDUWHWHVHLQZLUGPDQGLHPRQRORJLVFKHQ0HWKRGHQlQGHUQXQGYHUVXFKHQVLH]XYHUEHVVHUQ $EHUPDQ|IIQHWVLFKQLFKWHLQHU%HJHJQXQJGLHGDV6XEMHNWYHUlQGHUQRGHULQ%HZHJXQJEULQJHQ ZUGH 209 S pazio aperto /HEHQVNXQGLJHQGHP*DVWDOVHLQ5HÀH[LRQVNXQGLJHUEHJHJQHW8PGHP*DVWLQGHU3KLORVRSKLVFKHQ3UD[LVGLHQHQ]XN|QQHQQLPPWGHU3UDNWLNHUVLFKXQGVHLQH$QJHOHJHQKHLWHQ P|JOLFKVWYROOVWlQGLJDXVGHP6SLHO(UEOHLEWQDWUOLFKMHPDQGGHUVHLQHUVHLWVYRP/HEHQ JHSUlJWLVW'RFKHUNDQQGDGXUFKGDVVHUVLFK]XUFNQLPPW5DXPJHEHQVRGDVVGHU$QGHUH ]XU 0LWWHLOXQJ NRPPW =XJOHLFK JLOW GHU 3UDNWLNHU EHJLQQW VLFK LP (UIDKUXQJVUDXP GHV*DVWHV]XEHZHJHQ'DVLVWLQVRIHUQSDUDGR[DOVHUVLFKDXIGHQDQGHUHQHLQOlVVWLQGHP HU±DXILKQK|UHQG±GLHVHQEHLsichHLQOlVVWHLQH$UWZXQGHUEDUHU7DXVFK+|UHQGWUHWHLFK LQV/HEHQGHVDQGHUHQHLQEHJOHLWHLKQEHLGHPZDVHUVDJWXQGHUODXEHLKPLQGHPLFK HVDXIJUHLIHXQGWKHPDWLVLHUHGDVVHULQVHLQHQ(U]lKOXQJHQ9DULDWLRQHQYHUVXFKWXQGVLFK VR]XVDJHQLQDQGHUHQ0|JOLFKNHLWHQDXVSURELHUW'DVQHQQW*HUG$FKHQEDFKGDQQYLYL¿]LHren und dephlegmatisieren 'HU3KLORVRSKHPSIlQJWGHQ*DVWLQHLQHP5DXPYRQ$XIPHUNVDPNHLWXQG5FNKDOWORVLJNHLW'DVEUDXFKWDXFK9HUWUDXHQLQGLHHLJHQH3HUVRQbQJVWOLFKNHLWXQG8QVLFKHUKHLWLP 8PJDQJPLWDQGHUHQELQGHW]XVHKUXQGYHUOHLWHWGD]XVLFKGXUFK.RQ]HSWHXQG0DQXDOH DE]XVLFKHUQ:HQQPDQYRUGHUHLJHQHQ&RXUDJH$QJVWEHNRPPWÀLHKWPDQ]XPRQRORJLVFKHQ0HWKRGHQ /HRQGH+DDVYHUWULWWGLH$XIIDVVXQJGDVVHLQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UDNWLNHUVLFKDXFKQLFKW HLQQHKPHQODVVHQGUIHYRQGHP3KlQRPHQDOVRLUJHQGHLQHU/HEHQVSUREOHPDWLNGLHPLW GHP$QOLHJHQGHV*DVWHVYHUEXQGHQLVW6WDWWGHVVHQJHKHHVGDUXPGLH$UWXQG:HLVHwie er GDYRQUHGHWLQGHQ%OLFN]XQHKPHQ(UIROJW:LWWJHQVWHLQXQGPHLQWQXUVRODVVHVLFKGHU )OLHJHHLQ$XVZHJDXVGHP)OLHJHQJODVZHLVHQ0LWGHP%LOGGHV)OLHJHQJODVHVVHLGLHSHUV|QOLFKH.RQVWUXNWLRQGHU:HOWLP.RSIHLQHV0HQVFKHQJHPHLQWVHLQH'HVRULHQWLHUXQJGLH ]XVWDQGHNRPPHQNDQQZHQQHUVLFKVR]XVDJHQQLFKWULFKWLJVHOEVWHU]lKOW'HUEHWUHIIHQGH 0HQVFK LVW GD LQ VHLQH HLJHQHQ 'HXWXQJHQ YHUVWULFNW (V PDFKH HLQHQ JHZDOWLJHQ 8QWHUVFKLHGRELFKIRUPXOLHUHÄ'LH$QJVWNRPPWZLHGHU³RGHURELFKVDJHÄ,FKEHJLQQHPLFK HUQHXW]XlQJVWLJHQ³,P]ZHLWHQ)DOOELQLFKLP%HJULIIDXVGHU2SIHUUROOHKHUDXV]XWUHWHQ XQGLQHLQHQ'LDORJPLWPHLQHQ(UIDKUXQJHQ]XNRPPHQ :LU N|QQHQ GDYRQ DXVJHKHQ GDVV DXFK GHU *DVW YLHO ]X JHEHQ KDW XQG GDVV XQV VHLQ 6FKLFNVDO ÄDXI HLQH VROFKH :HLVH EHUKUHQ NDQQ GDVV GLH %HZHJXQJ HLQHU ZHVHQWOLFKHQ PHQVFKOLFKHQ(UIDKUXQJLQ*DQJNRPPW³ 'LHIROJHQGHQ=LWDWHYRQ$QGHUV/LQGVHWKZLH $QPHUNXQJ 6LFK GDUDXI HLQODVVHQG ¿QGHW PDQ LQ GLH %HZHJXQJ GHV9HUVWHKHQV GLH GHQ$XVGUXFN GHV *DVWHV anerkennt und zugleich erkennt:LU YHU]LFKWHQ GDEHL GDUDXI 'D]XDXFK$FKHQEDFKPLWGHP1HRORJLVPXVÄ(LQJHODVVHQKHLW³,QGHU%HUDWXQJELQLFK]XQlFKVWHLQPDOJHIRUGHUWDOVGHUGHUK|UW'DV=XK|UHQLVWGLH6HHOHGHV*HVSUlFKV0DQN|QQWHVDJHQGDV%LOG IUGLH%HUDWXQJVVLWXDWLRQLVWGLHVGDVVLFKMHPDQGHPPHLQ2KUOHLKHhEULJHQVHLQJURDUWLJHV%LOG :HQQLFKPHLQ2KULKPOHLKHKDWHUHLQGULWWHV8QGGLHVHVGULWWH2KUKDWHU]XVHLQHU1XW]QLHXQJ HUNDQQGDPLWK|UHQVLFKVHOEHUDOVVHLHVVHLQHLJHQHV$EHUJOHLFK]HLWLJLVWHVHEHQGRFKGDVHLQHV DQGHUHQ8QGGLHVHIHLQH'LIIHUHQ]GLHPDFKWHLJHQWOLFKGLHSURGXNWLYH.UDIWGHV=XK|UHQVDXV,FK KDEHLPPHUJHGDFKWGDIUPVVWHPDQHLQHLJHQHV:RUWHU¿QGHQIUGLHVH6LWXDWLRQGHV=XK|UHQV 8QGHVJLEWHLQ:RUWGDVLFKJHUQHYHUEUHLWHQZUGHGDVVWHKWQLFKWLP'XGHQ'LHVH6LWXDWLRQZUGH LFKQHQQHQ(LQJHODVVHQKHLW'HUSKLORVRSKLVFKH3UDNWLNHUKDWVHLQHP*DVWJHJHQEHUGLH+DOWXQJGHU (LQJHODVVHQKHLW]XEHQ'DVWHFNW*HODVVHQKHLWGULQGDVWHFNWVLFKHLQODVVHQGULQ'LHVH.RPELQDWLRQ YRQ*HODVVHQKHLWXQGHLQODVVHQGLHVH(LQJHODVVHQKHLWLVWGLH%HUHLWVFKDIWIUHLQHQDQGHUHQGD]X VHLQDOVGHUGHUHULVW1XUGDQQZHQQPLUGDVJHOLQJWPLFKDXIMHPDQGHQHLQ]XODVVHQKDWGHUDQGHUH GLH&KDQFHVLFKVHLQHUVHLWV±ZDVLFKIULKQHUKRIIH±VLFK]XlQGHUQ 210 Dialog in philosophischer Praxis S 7KRPDV*XWNQHFKW LP9RUDXV]XZLVVHQZDVGHUDQGHUHPHLQWXQGVDJHQZLUGÄ:HQQZLUGDUDXIYHU]LFKWHQ LP9RUDXV]XZLVVHQZRYRQGHU$XVGUXFNHLQHV*DVWHVKDQGHOWLQGHPZLUHVZDJHQGHQ $XVGUXFN(LQGUXFNDXIXQVPDFKHQ]XODVVHQ±VR]XVDJHQXQJHVFKW]WGXUFKLUJHQGHLQ9RUZLVVHQVRWXQZLUGLHVXPGLH(U]lKOXQJXQG/HEHQVWKHPDWLNGHV*DVWHVHUOHEEDUXQGDQVFKDXOLFKHUVFKHLQHQODVVHQ]XN|QQHQ³'HU(IIHNW'DQQZLUGVLFKGHU*DVWDXIHLQHPHKU EHZXVVWH:HLVHVHOEVWK|UHQN|QQHQ8QGGLHVHUODXEWLKPHUVWHLQHHLJHQVWlQGLJH2ULHQWLHUXQJLQGHP]X¿QGHQZDVHUVHOEVWVDJW'HU2UWGHU2ULHQWLHUXQJHQWVWHKWLP*HVSUlFK ÄXQGGHU*DVWEHNRPPWGXUFKGDV*HVSUlFKHLQH0|JOLFKNHLW]X1HXRULHQWLHUXQJ'HU*DVW EHJLQQWVHLQ/HEHQLQHLQHPQHXHQ/LFKW]XVHKHQ³ (VLVWGHU)HKOHUGHU8QHUIDKUHQHQ]XVFKQHOOZLVVHQ]XZROOHQZRUEHUGHU*DVWVSULFKW XQGZRUXPHVLKPÄHLJHQWOLFK³JHKW0DQPXVVVLFKVWDWWGHVVHQHLQODVVHQDOVMHPDQGGHU ]XPHUVWHQ0DOHLQHHLQPDOLJH*HVFKLFKWHHUIlKUWXQGGDEHLLQV6WDXQHQJHUDWHQ'HU$QIlQJHULQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LVDQWL]LSLHUW(UIDKUXQJXQGJHUDGHGDVPDFKWJHK|UORVXQGEOLQG JHJHQEHUGHQMHXUVSUQJOLFKHQ(UIDKUXQJHQ:HUÄHUIDKUHQ³WXWEULQJWVLFKJHUDGHXP(UIDKUXQJ 'LDORJ LVW GDV *HVFKHQN GHU 7HLOKDEH 6ROFKH 7HLOKDEH LVW YRU GHQ :|UWHUQ JHJHEHQ YRU GHQ %HJULIIHQ YRU DOOHP ,GHQWL¿]LHUWHQ 'LH *UXQGDQQDKPH XQG *UXQGYRUDXVVHW]XQJ GHU +HUPHQHXWLN XQG GHU 3KlQRPHQRORJLH EHVDJW GDVV XQVHU %HZXVVWVHLQ GHU :HOW QLFKW YRQ HLQHU %HREDFKWXQJ GHU:HOW YRQ DXHQ VWDPPW VRQGHUQ DXV HLQHU7HLOKDEH DOVR GHP %HZHJWZHUGHQYRQGHU:HOW(QWVFKHLGHQGLVWGDVVPDQYRQHWZDVEHUKUWRGHUHUJULIIHQLVW QXUGDUDXVHQWZLFNHOWVLFKGDV9HUVWHKHQXPGDVVLFK*DVWXQG*DVWJHEHULQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU 3UD[LVEHPKHQZHQQVLHWDWVlFKOLFKLQGLDORJLVFKHU:HLVHLP*HVSUlFKYHUEXQGHQVLQG)U GLHVHHFKWH%HJHJQXQJLVWGHU$XVGUXFNÄLQ.RQWDNWNRPPHQ³YLHO]XVFKZDFK3HULFKRUHVH WULIIWHVVFKRQHKHU $QGHUV/LQGVHWKYRQGHPLFKVRYLHOEHU3UD[LVJHVSUlFKHJHOHUQWXPQLFKW]XVDJHQ DEJHVFKDXWKDEHVDJWGDVVGHU'LDORJLQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LVHLQ3UR]HVVZHUGHQVROOWHLQ GHPHLQH/HEHQVWKHPDWLNKHUYRUWUHWHQNDQQ,QGLHVHP3UR]HVVN|QQH9RUZLVVHQMHJOLFKHU$UW KLOIUHLFKRGHUDEHUDXFKKLQGHUOLFKVHLQ+LQGHUOLFKJHUDGHGDQQZHQQPDQPHLQWDOO]XJXW 0DQNDQQGHP(U]lKOWHQIROJHQZLHHLQHP5RPDQ8QGHLQHQ5RPDQOHVHQNDQQGLHJOHLFKH:LUNXQJ KDEHQZLHHLQ*HVSUlFKLQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LV(VVFKHLQWGDVVGLH6HHOVRUJHLQ5XVVODQGGXUFKGLH JURHQUXVVLVFKHQ'LFKWHUJHOHLVWHWZLUGZREHLKLHUGLH'LIIHUHQ]YRQ6HHOVRUJH 3V\FKR 7KHUDSLH XQG3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LVDXIJOFNOLFKH:HLVHXQWHUODXIHQZLUG:DVZLULQJURHU$QVFKDXOLFKNHLW PLWGHU.UDIWXQVHUHU)DQWDVLHDXIIDVVHQKDWVHLQHQ8UVSUXQJQLFKWQXULQXQV*HPHLQVDPPLWGHP *DVWZHUGHQZLUPLWHLQHP2UWYHUWUDXWGHQZLUGDQQ]XVDPPHQHUIRUVFKHQN|QQHQ'DVJLEWGHP *HVSUlFKVHLQH/HEHQGLJNHLWXQGEULQJWGLH3DUWQHUDXI$XJHQK|KH 6HOEVWZHQQPDQLQGHU(LQVWHOOXQJHWZDV%HGHXWHQGHVKHUDXVEULQJHQ]XZROOHQLQGHPZDVHU]lKOW ZLUG]XHLQHUULFKWLJHQ'LDJQRVHNRPPWNDQQGLHVRPlFKWLJZHUGHQZLHXQVHUH6RQQHGLHPLWGHP 7DJHVOLFKWGDIUVRUJWQLFKWVYRQGHQ$EHUPLOOLRQHQ6WHUQHQ]XVHKHQ(VPXVVJOHLFKVDP1DFKWVHLQ XP]XHQWGHFNHQGDVVHVYLHOH6RQQHQJLEW,FKZLOOGDV%LOGQLFKWEHUVWUDSD]LHUHQVRQGHUQQXUVDJHQGDVVHLQH]XWUHIIHQGH'LDJQRVHZLFKWLJHDQGHUH(LQVLFKWHQ]XGHUNRPSOH[H(U]lKOXQJHQIKUHQ N|QQHQ YHUVWHOOHQ NDQQ 'LH (PSIlQJOLFKNHLW XQG GLH %HUHLWVFKDIW VLFK EHUKUHQ XQG EHZHJHQ ]X ODVVHQVFKZLQGHQUDSLGH:HUIUDOOHVHLQH7KHRULHKDWYHUOHJWGDQQGDVYRP*DVW9RUJHEUDFKWHDQ HLQHQIUHPGHQ2UW$XFKKLHUN|QQWHPDQ:LWWJHQVWHLQDOV=HXJHQEHPKHQGHUNULWLVLHUWGDVV3KLORVRSKHQPLWGHQ:|UWHUQGHU$OOWDJVVSUDFKH:RONHQNXFNXFNVKHLPHHUULFKWHQVLFKDEHUGHP/HEHQ HQWIUHPGHQ 211 S pazio aperto ]XZLVVHQZDV6DFKHLVW=LHUGHGHV3KLORVRSKLVFKHQ3UDNWLNHUVLVWZHGHU:LVVHQQRFK(ORTXHQ]9LHOPHKUVFKPFNWLKQHLQHJHZLVVH%HJULIIVVWXW]LJNHLW'DVHUOHLFKWHUWGDV=XK|UHQ GLHHLJHQWOLFKH.XQVW :HQQHVQXQGDUXPJHKWGHP*DVW]XHUODXEHQVHLQ/HEHQ]XHU]lKOHQVWHKHQZLUYRUGHP 3DUDGR[ GDVV GLH 3KLORVRSKLVFKH 3UD[LV ]ZDU GLDORJLVFK YROO]RJHQ ZLUG DEHU QLFKW LQ GHU *HVWDOWRGHU)RUPGHV'LDORJVVRQGHUQHEHQGHU(U]lKOXQJ'HQQHLJHQWOLFKJHVFKLHKWGDV (U]lKOHQPHLVWRKQHGDVVHVHLQH=ZLHVSUDFKHLPIRUPDOHQ6LQQJlEHZHQQJOHLFKLQGLDORJLVFKHU$WPRVSKlUHXQGHEHQDXIÄJHVSUlFKLJH³:HLVH'HU*HVFKLFKWHQHU]lKOHQGH0HQVFK GHPHLQDQGHUHU]XK|UW ]XK|UHQPXVV ZLOOZDVLKP]XVW|WLQVHLQ]HUULVVHQHV/HEHQLQWHJULHUHQ*HVFKLFKWHQHU]lKOHQ]XGUIHQEHGHXWHWPLWGHP=XIlOOLJHQLQV5HLQH]XNRPPHQ (VZLUG,GHQWLWlWJHELOGHWHVJHKWXPGHQPRGXVYLYHQGLPLWGHU:DKUKHLWXQGQLFKW]XOHW]W XP9HUJDQJHQKHLWVEHZlOWLJXQJDOVRXP%HIUHLXQJIUGDV+LHUXQG-HW]W :RDEHUHLQZLUNOLFKHV=ZLHJHVSUlFK3ODW]JUHLIWPXVVPDQVLFK±GDVZlUHYRQ6RNUDWHV ]XOHUQHQ±XQEHOLHEWPDFKHQN|QQHQGHPDQGHUQ]XOLHEHvorGLHVHP LQGHVVHQ$QJHVLFKW WDSIHUVHLQLKQJHJHQVHLQHQYHUVWlQGOLFKHQ:XQVFKHVOHLFKWHU]XKDEHQLQ6FKXW]QHKPHQ XQGIRUGHUQ(VJLEW]XYLHOH6FKPHLFKOHULQGLHVHU:HOW6LHKDOWHQVLFKYLHOOHLFKWIUK|ÀLFK $EHULQ:DKUKHLWP|FKWHQVLHGHQ$QGHUHQVFKQHOOORVZHUGHQ'HVKDOEEHVWlUNHQVLHOLHEHU DOVGDVVVLHZLGHUVSUHFKHQ3KLORVRSKLHDEHUHUOHLFKWHUWGDV/HEHQQLFKWVRQGHUQYHUWLHIWHV 'DQQK|UWGHU3UDNWLNHUDXFK2EHUW|QHXQGHLQHQ8QWHUWRQ'LHVHQEHVFKZHUHQGHQ5HLFKWXP KDQGHOWVLFKGHU*DVWLQGHU3KLORVRSKLVFKHQ3UD[LVHLQ±XQGEH]DKOWGDIUVRJDU LQYHUVFKLHGHQHU+LQVLFKWKDWGLHVVHLQHQ3UHLV Ä,QGHPPDQHLQHPDQGHUHQVHLQH)UDJHQVFKZHUPDFKW QLPPWPDQLKQHUQVWXQGLQGHPPDQLKQHUQVWQLPPWEHNRPPWVHLQ/HEHQHLQ*HZLFKW 3KLORVRSKLVFKH3UD[LVLVWNHLQH(UOHLFKWHUXQJVRQGHUQHLQH(UVFKZHUXQJGHU9HUWLHIXQJVDEVLFKWZHJHQ0DQN|QQWHJHUDGH]XLQHLQHP%LOGVDJHQ:HUSKLORVRSKLVFKEHODVWHWZLUGGHU KlQJWZLHHLQ6FKLIIWLHIHULP:DVVHUXQGGHU.LHOJHKWUXKLJHU'RUWZRHUHUOHLFKWHUWZLUG GDZDFNHOWGDV6FKLIIFKHQREHQDXIMHGHU:HOOH³'LHÄ0HWKRGH³GHU3KLORVRSKLVFKHQ3UD[LVVROODOVRQLFKWVLFKHUVWHOOHQGDVVHLQYRUDXVJHSODQWHV=LHOHUUHLFKWZLUGVRQGHUQVLHVROO HUP|JOLFKHQGDVVGUlQJHQGH7KHPHQGHV/HEHQVEHVSURFKHQZHUGHQN|QQHQ'LHVHV%HVSUHFKHQYRQXQXPJlQJOLFKHQ/HEHQVWKHPHQIKUW]XP%HZXVVWZHUGHQYRQ:HVHQWOLFKHP(V EUDXFKW=HLWGLH=HLWDQGLH3ODWRQLP%ULHIHULQQHUW ,FKVFKOLHHPLWGHU]XVDPPHQIDVVHQGHQ7KHVH'LH3KLORVRSKLHGLHHWZDVWDXJWLVW±RE LQ3KLORVRSKLVFKHU3UD[LVRGHUDQGHUVZR±3KLORVRSKLHUHQLP*HVSUlFK3KLORVRSKLHLVWNHLQH/HKUHVRQGHUQ3UD[LV3UD[LVGHU3KLORVRSKLH3KLORVRSKLHUHQ7KHPDGHV3KLORVRSKLHUHQV VLQGGLHZLFKWLJHQPHQVFKOLFKHQ$QJHOHJHQKHLWHQ)ROJHQZLUGHU,QWXLWLRQGHUELRJUD¿VFK RULHQWLHUWHQ 3KLORVRSKLH GHU$QWLNH EHVWHKW GDV 0HQVFKOLFKH VHOEVW ZHVHQWOLFK LP 'LDORJ 'DQQLVWGLH3KLORVRSKLVFKH3UD[LVHLQDXVJH]HLFKQHWHU2UWGHU0HQVFKZHUGXQJGHV0HQVFKHQ (LQXQXPJlQJOLFKHV7KHPDGHU0HQVFKHQLVWDXFKGLH(QJHGHU=HLW6LHEHGUlQJWPLFK 'LH%LOGZRUWHJHKHQ]XUFNDXI5GLJHU6DIUDQVNL 3KLORVRSKLHLVWLP*DQ]HQGLDORJLVFKYHUIDVVW$OOHLQVFKRQEHUGLH)UDJHZDVGHQQ3KLORVRSKLH GDV 3KLORVRSKLHUHQ VHLEH¿QGHQZLU3KLORVRSKLHUHQGHXQVLQHLQHPHQGORVHQ*HVSUlFK8PHVPLWHLQHP :RUWYRQ%ODLVH3DVFDODXIGLH6SLW]H]XWUHLEHQ$XFKZHUVLFKQXUEHU3KLORVRSKLHOXVWLJPDFKW SKLORVRSKLHUWEHUHLWV0DQNDQQQLFKWQLFKWSKLORVRSKLHUHQXP3DXO:DW]ODZLFN]XSDURGLHUHQ2GHU PLW.DUO3RSSHUJHVDJW$OOH0HQVFKHQVLQG3KLORVRSKHQQXUWDXJWQLFKWMHGH3KLORVRSKLHHWZDV 212